Knights of Pen and Paper – WISE Score & Parent Review | Screenwise

Knights of Pen and Paper

Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

game2012

65%

WISE Score

67%

IGDB

A meta RPG where you control both the nerds around the table and their pixelated heroes—charming concept, grindy execution.

Knights of Pen and Paper

game

2012

65%

WISE Score

67%

IGDB

A meta RPG where you control both the nerds around the table and their pixelated heroes—charming concept, grindy execution.

Jump to

Also rated on

IGDB67

View →

Where to Play

Screenwise Verdict

Knights of Pen and Paper has a genuinely clever hook—you're managing both the D&D players sitting around the table AND their in-game avatars. The pixel art is charming, the concept is creative, and there's no predatory monetization to worry about.

But here's the thing: it's pretty grindy. Reddit users aren't wrong when they say it's mostly combat with limited exploration or story depth. The Teen rating (blood, suggestive themes, language) means it's not for younger kids anyway, and the niche humor really only lands if your kid is already into retro RPGs or tabletop gaming.

It's a decent pick for the right audience—tweens and teens who love turn-based strategy and appreciate the meta-gaming joke. Just don't expect it to be a must-play masterpiece. It's more of a "oh that's a fun idea" game that overstays its welcome after a few hours.

Age Fit

Best for ages 11-16 who already enjoy turn-based RPGs or tabletop gaming culture. The Teen rating, repetitive gameplay, and niche humor mean younger kids will likely bounce off it, while older teens may find it too grindy unless they're retro gaming enthusiasts.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

Turn-based RPG that celebrates tabletop gaming culture with cartoony violence and some blood effects. ESRB rates the +1 Edition as Teen for Violence, Blood, Suggestive Themes, and Language. The tone is lighthearted and nostalgic, modeling cooperation through party-based gameplay, though some mature humor and references keep it from being squeaky clean.

Imaginative

Clever meta-concept that puts you in control of both the players around a tabletop AND their in-game characters. The retro pixel art and pen-and-paper framing device show genuine creativity, blending classic Final Fantasy-style RPG mechanics with D&D culture. Character customization and party-building invite strategic thinking, though some Reddit users note it's combat-heavy with less exploration than expected.

Safe

Users interact online but there's no in-game chat, no loot boxes, and no in-app purchases in the original version. Content includes cartoony violence with some blood, suggestive themes, and language per ESRB. Knights of Pen and Paper 2 adds references to alcohol, tobacco, drugs, and profanity according to SaferKid. The game is straightforward without manipulative loops, but the Teen rating means parents should preview before handing to younger kids.

Enriching

Introduces kids to tabletop RPG concepts like party composition, turn-based strategy, and resource management. The meta-gaming layer is intellectually interesting for those who appreciate the reference. However, Reddit feedback suggests it's repetitive and combat-focused without much narrative depth or exploration. It's entertaining for RPG fans but doesn't offer substantial skill-building or meaningful takeaways beyond genre familiarity.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Clever meta-gaming concept that celebrates tabletop RPG culture and introduces D&D-style party mechanics
Retro pixel art and turn-based combat will appeal to kids who love classic Final Fantasy or nostalgic gaming
No predatory monetization in the original—just straightforward RPG gameplay
Available across tons of platforms (mobile, Switch, PC, consoles) so easy to access

⚠

What to Watch For

Teen rating means cartoony violence with blood, some suggestive themes, and mild language—preview first for sensitive kids
Sequels add references to alcohol, tobacco, and drugs according to parent reviews
Combat-heavy and repetitive—some players find it grindy and lacking in story depth
The humor and references work best for kids already into retro gaming or tabletop culture

Conversation Starters

"Have you ever played Dungeons & Dragons or heard of it? This game is kind of like that—what do you think about controlling both the players and the characters?"
"Which character class did you pick for your party? Why do you think having different roles (like a tank, healer, damage dealer) matters in a game?"
"The game makes fun of old-school RPG tropes—what's the funniest or weirdest thing you've noticed?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic