Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
This is solid middle-grade fantasy that respects its audience enough to include real consequences and moral complexity. Collins doesn't pull punches—characters die, war is ugly, prejudice runs deep—but she keeps it age-appropriate through the lens of an 11-year-old trying to find his dad and protect his baby sister.
The talking-animal thing could feel derivative (very Redwall), but the urban fantasy portal angle and the prophecy structure keep it fresh enough. Parents love that Gregor shows strong character without being preachy, and kids apparently devour the series once they're hooked.
The main caveat: this is darker than the cover suggests. If your kid melts down when a side character in a movie gets hurt, wait a year or two. But for kids ready to handle stakes and sadness in their fantasy, this is a great bridge between elementary and YA.
Age Fit
Best for ages 8-13, especially kids ready to graduate from Magic Tree House but not quite ready for full YA. The violence and themes are more intense than typical middle-grade fare, so know your kid. Adults won't likely pick this up unless they're Collins completists.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
78
Gregor is a genuinely good kid who takes care of his toddler sister Boots and makes tough moral choices throughout. The book models responsibility, family loyalty, and cooperation across species lines. There's war and battle violence that gets intense, and some characters die, which earns parent warnings but isn't gratuitous. The pacing is adventure-driven without being chaotic, and the emotional tone stays grounded in Gregor's very relatable worry about his missing father.
Imaginative
82
Collins built an entire underground world beneath NYC with giant talking bats, cockroaches, spiders, and rats living in uneasy tension with humans. The prophecy structure and world-building invite curiosity about how this ecosystem works. It's clearly inspired by Redwall-style talking animals but adds its own spin with the urban fantasy portal element. The concept is original enough to spark imagination, though it's more about exploring Collins' world than creating your own.
Safe
72
This is a middle-grade fantasy with real stakes: there are battles, war, discrimination themes, and character deaths. Parents consistently note 'scary and sad parts' and that 'some characters don't make it.' It's not graphic or gory, but it's emotionally heavy for younger or sensitive readers. No sexual content, no language issues. The violence is fantasy combat (swords, claws) rather than realistic brutality. Safe for the intended audience (upper elementary/middle school) but could be too intense for younger kids expecting a light adventure.
Enriching
76
The book tackles prejudice, war, and the cost of violence in ways that invite real thought. Gregor faces moral dilemmas without easy answers, and the rat discrimination subplot mirrors real-world bias. Reviews highlight 'thought provoking questions' and 'good messages throughout.' It builds reading stamina for middle-grade readers transitioning to longer chapter books. The prophecy structure adds narrative complexity. Entertaining enough to keep kids turning pages while sneaking in themes about empathy across differences.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
Suzanne Collins wrote this before Hunger Games, and you can see her talent for creating high-stakes worlds where kids have to make impossible choices
Gregor is a genuinely likable protagonist—responsible big brother energy, morally grounded, no chosen-one ego
The two-year-old sister Boots is apparently adorable enough that kids remember her years later
Tackles prejudice and the cycle of violence in a fantasy context that invites real conversations about bias and revenge
Moves fast enough to hook reluctant readers while building a complex world with talking animals and prophecy intrigue
⚠
What to Watch For
This is NOT a light romp—there are battles, war, and characters die. Parents consistently flag the 'scary and sad parts'
The rat discrimination subplot is heavy and might need context for younger readers
First in a five-book series that apparently gets darker as it goes
Some kids will breeze through this at 8; others won't be ready until 10 or 11
Conversation Starters
"Why do you think the humans and rats hate each other so much? Have you ever seen people treat a group unfairly like that?"
"Gregor has to take care of Boots the whole time. What would it be like to be on an adventure with a toddler?"
"The prophecy says Gregor is supposed to be a warrior, but he doesn't want to fight. What would you do?"
"Which Underland creature would you want as a friend—the bats, the cockroaches, or the spiders?"
