Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
Emily Henry is the gold standard for romance that doesn't treat its readers like they're simple. Funny Story takes a messy, painful premise—your fiancé leaving you for his childhood best friend—and turns it into something that feels like a warm Michigan summer evening.
The banter is sharp, the characters have actual depth, and the emotional stakes feel real. The roommate dynamic between a buttoned-up children's librarian and a scruffy, heartbroken Miles is where the book really finds its rhythm.
It’s an emotionally intelligent and genuinely funny 'drop everything and read it' recommendation for adults. Just keep in mind it’s a romance novel for grown-ups; the sex is on the page and the language is salty. If your teen is raiding your nightstand, maybe have a chat about the 'spice' level first.
Age Fit
This is strictly for adults or older, mature teens who are already deep into 'BookTok' romances. It’s got explicit scenes, so keep it off the middle school shelf.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
80
The book centers on healthy emotional processing and finding a support system after a traumatic life event. It models vulnerability and honesty in relationships, though the 'fake dating' premise starts with a bit of petty revenge.
Imaginative
72
While it relies on established romance tropes like 'fake dating' and 'opposites attract,' Henry's specific character voices and the vivid Michigan lakeside setting feel fresh and well-realized.
Safe
45
This is an adult novel with explicit 'open-door' sexual content. It is not intended for children and contains material that would be inappropriate for a younger reader to encounter unexpectedly.
Enriching
85
It offers high emotional intelligence regarding boundaries, self-worth, and navigating the fallout of parental neglect. It’s a great study in how to rebuild an identity that isn't dependent on a partner.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
Emily Henry writes dialogue that actually sounds like people you’d want to grab a drink with.
It handles the 'fake dating' trope with more heart and less cheese than your average rom-com.
The exploration of how we handle betrayal and rebuild our own sense of self is surprisingly deep.
The Michigan lake-town setting is so vivid it basically counts as a vacation for your brain.
⚠
What to Watch For
This is an R-rated book in terms of sexual content; the 'spice' is definitely on the page.
Themes of emotional neglect from parents and the pain of a public breakup might hit close to home for some.
Conversation Starters
"Is it possible to actually 'fake' date someone without catching feelings, or is that just a movie myth?"
"Daphne’s coworkers thought she was in witness protection—what’s the weirdest thing your coworkers probably think about you?"
"How do you start over when your entire identity was tied to a person who just walked out?"
"Why do we often fall for the person who is the exact opposite of what we thought we wanted?"