Is this book as scary as the Netflix movies?

Generally, no. The Netflix movies are rated R for a reason—they have much more graphic violence and gore. The books are written for a teen audience and rely more on suspense and 'implied' danger, though they are still darker than Goosebumps.

Do you need to read the other Fear Street books first?

Not at all. Shadyside is the shared setting, but almost all Fear Street books, including these two, are standalone stories. You can jump in anywhere.

What is the 'lust' mentioned in the synopsis?

In Stine-speak, this usually just means intense high school crushes and some heavy pining. It's more about 'teen drama' and obsession than anything sexually explicit.

Is it appropriate for a 10-year-old?

If they are a 'horror kid' who has finished every Goosebumps book and wants more, they'll likely be fine. Just know that people actually die in these books, unlike the 'gotcha' endings of Stine's younger series.

Fear Street Super Thriller: Secrets – WISE Score & Parent Review | Screenwise

Fear Street Super Thriller: Secrets

Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

book2016

70%

WISE Score

4.8

Amazon

R.L. Stine's classic teen-horror formula gets a double-feature update where mysterious girls and bags of cash lead to exactly the trouble you'd expect.

Fear Street Super Thriller: Secrets

book

2016

70%

WISE Score

4.8

Amazon

R.L. Stine's classic teen-horror formula gets a double-feature update where mysterious girls and bags of cash lead to exactly the trouble you'd expect.

4.8

Jump to

Also rated on

4.8

View →

Where to Read

Amazon

Barnes & Noble

Libby

Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased, but as an Amazon Associate, Screenwise earns an affiliate fee if you buy a book or game by clicking one of our links. We don't get any credit if you just Google it instead :)

Screenwise Verdict

This is popcorn for the brain, and that's a good thing. If you have a teen who has 'checked out' of reading, R.L. Stine is often the easiest way back in. It’s fast, it’s dramatic, and it doesn’t demand a high cognitive load, making it a perfect alternative to a mindless phone scroll.

While the Fear Street movies on Netflix brought a new generation to Shadyside, the books remain the better bet for building the language comprehension side of the reading rope. You’re getting two stories here—The Lost Girl and Can You Keep a Secret?—both of which lean heavily into the 'teens in over their heads' trope that Stine perfected decades ago.

Age Fit

Best for ages 12 to 17. It's written for the teen/YA market, so while a horror-loving 10-year-old could handle it, the 'teen drama' elements are definitely aimed at middle and high schoolers.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

It's R.L. Stine, so the plot is fueled by greed, lust, and violence. It's not meant to be 'clean,' but it stays within the boundaries of teen-targeted campy horror.

Imaginative

Stine is the master of the narrative hook and the twist ending. While formulaic, these stories encourage readers to predict and unravel mysteries.

Safe

As a book, it's free from the tracking and algorithmic traps of digital media. The content is clearly labeled as horror, so the 'danger' isn't a surprise.

Enriching

Excellent for building the language comprehension strands of literacy. Stine's punchy prose is a classic 'gateway drug' for reluctant readers.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Master of the cliffhanger R.L. Stine knows exactly how to keep a kid turning pages, which is a win for building reading stamina.
Low-stakes scares provide a safe way for teens to process intense emotions like fear and suspense without the graphic visuals of modern horror movies.
Literacy gateway for kids who aren't into 'literature' but love a fast-paced, plot-driven mystery.

⚠

What to Watch For

The Fear Street series is a significant step up from Goosebumps in terms of violence and mature themes like 'lust' and 'greed.'
In Can You Keep a Secret?, the plot revolves around a bag of money and ends in multiple deaths, which might be heavy for more sensitive younger readers.

Conversation Starters

"If you and your friends found a bag of money in the woods, would you keep it or report it?"
"Why do you think Michael is so obsessed with the 'mysterious new girl' even when things start getting weird?"
"Does a story need a happy ending to be good, or do you prefer the darker twists in Fear Street?"

Deep Dive

The Stine Machine and the Reading Rope

We often talk about literacy as if it's just about phonics, but the other half of the battle is language comprehension—vocabulary, narrative structure, and verbal reasoning. R.L. Stine is a secret weapon here. His writing isn't 'high art,' but it is mechanically perfect for building a reader's internal engine. He uses short chapters, constant cliffhangers, and very clear cause-and-effect plotting. For a kid who finds long, descriptive novels boring, this is the antidote.

Fear Street is the older, grittier sibling to Goosebumps. While Goosebumps usually deals with monsters and 'safe' scares, Fear Street deals with human malice. In this volume, you're looking at themes of greed and the consequences of keeping secrets. It’s a bit campy by 2026 standards, but the psychological tension of 'should we keep the money?' is a timeless hook.

If your kid watched the Netflix trilogy, they'll recognize the vibe of Shadyside, but the books are generally less graphic than the films. It’s a solid way to bridge the gap between 'kid books' and adult thrillers.

What Parents Ask

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic

Writing about Fear Street Super Thriller: Secrets? Put this WISE score on your site