Elsbeth is pleasant, competent network television—a crime procedural that doesn't take itself too seriously. Carrie Preston's charm elevates what could be standard CBS fare into something genuinely enjoyable, especially if you're already a fan from The Good Wife days.

For families, it's a decent option for older teens who want something lighter than true crime but more substantial than pure fluff. The show models intelligence and empathy, and the quirky protagonist is a refreshing change from brooding detectives. That said, it's still a show where someone dies every episode, so this isn't family movie night for the under-13 crowd.

The WISE score of 69 reflects its solid-but-not-spectacular quality: good enough to recommend to the right audience, but not must-watch TV. If your teen likes mysteries and you want something you can watch together without cringing, Elsbeth delivers. Just know you're getting well-executed network procedural comfort food, not prestige television.