This is a solid, heartwarming sequel that trades some of the original's inventive premise for deeper emotional territory. It's not going to change anyone's life, but it's exactly what it promises: a sweet, funny holiday romance with enough substance to feel worthwhile.

The real strength here is how it handles Lily's grief without being heavy-handed. Her grandfather's heart attack has dimmed her usual sparkle, and watching her friends and boyfriend rally around her feels genuine rather than saccharine. The book respects that you can't just snap out of sadness, even during your favorite season.

The writing is witty and sharp—Cohn and Levithan know how to write teen dialogue that doesn't make you cringe. The NYC holiday setting is pure wish-fulfillment in the best way. This isn't groundbreaking literature, but it's a perfectly enjoyable read for teens who want romance, humor, and a little emotional depth wrapped in holiday magic.

If your teen liked the first book, they'll probably love this one. If they're new to the series, start with Book of Dares—but either way, this is safe, wholesome entertainment that models healthy relationships and emotional resilience without being preachy about it.