Daddy's Roommate – WISE Score & Parent Review | Screenwise

Daddy's Roommate

Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

book1994

58%

WISE Score

4.3

Amazon

Pioneering 1990 picture book about a kid with a gay dad—historically important but painfully dated and more museum piece than page-turner.

Daddy's Roommate

book

1994

58%

WISE Score

4.3

Amazon

Pioneering 1990 picture book about a kid with a gay dad—historically important but painfully dated and more museum piece than page-turner.

4.3

Jump to

Also rated on

4.3

View →

Where to Read

Amazon

Barnes & Noble

Libby

Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased, but as an Amazon Associate, Screenwise earns an affiliate fee if you buy a book or game by clicking one of our links. We don't get any credit if you just Google it instead :)

Screenwise Verdict

Here's the truth: Daddy's Roommate was brave and necessary in 1990. It broke ground. It gave kids with gay parents a mirror when almost nothing else existed.

But in 2025? It's a relic. The illustrations look like they were made in Microsoft Paint. The text is so spare it barely qualifies as a story. A modern kid picking this up will be bored within 30 seconds, regardless of their family structure.

If you need a book about LGBTQ+ families, there are so many better options now—books with actual plots, beautiful art, and characters kids want to spend time with. This one belongs in a 'history of children's literature' collection, not on your nightstand.

That said: if your school district is banning it (yes, this still happens), maybe check it out just to see what the fuss is about. Spoiler alert: there's literally nothing objectionable unless you think gay people existing is objectionable, in which case, well, we probably aren't your people anyway.

Age Fit

Intended for ages 4-8 (grades PreK-2) based on reading level and content. The subject matter is appropriate for that range, though modern kids may find the presentation boring. Realistically most useful for families directly affected by similar situations or educators intentionally teaching about family diversity.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

Matter-of-fact portrayal of a child's experience with divorce and a parent's same-sex relationship. Shows everyday activities (eating, chores, playing) in a normalized, gentle way. The tone is respectful and age-appropriate for early readers, modeling acceptance and straightforward communication about family structures.

Imaginative

This is a straightforward social-realist picture book focused on representation and normalization rather than creative storytelling. It's more of a mirror book than a window—important for its time, but doesn't invite much creative exploration, world-building, or imaginative play. The illustrations are simple and functional rather than artistically compelling.

Safe

Extremely safe content—no violence, scary imagery, or inappropriate material. Shows affection (the dad and his partner are described as 'loving') in an age-appropriate, non-graphic way. The controversy around this book is entirely political/cultural, not content-based. For families comfortable with LGBTQ+ representation, there are zero safety concerns. Docked slightly only because it's been a flashpoint in book bans, which means some families will encounter unexpected pushback.

Enriching

Groundbreaking for 1990 (published 1990, not 1994 as listed) as one of the first children's books to depict a gay parent. Offers important representation and can help kids understand diverse family structures. Builds empathy and normalizes LGBTQ+ relationships. However, it's more of a social tool than a rich literary experience—minimal narrative arc, simple vocabulary, and dated illustrations limit its broader enrichment value.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

One of the first children's books to show a same-sex couple, offering representation that was radical for its time
Straightforward, no-drama approach to explaining divorce and new family structures
Can validate kids with LGBTQ+ parents and normalize diverse families for others
Short and simple enough for early readers (grades 1-2) to tackle independently

⚠

What to Watch For

The illustrations and text feel extremely dated—think early-90s clip art vibes that won't grab modern kids
It's been banned in Florida and other districts, so be prepared for potential school/community controversy
More of a conversation starter than an engaging story—there's barely a plot
Better, more engaging LGBTQ+ family books exist now (Heather Has Two Mommies updated edition, And Tango Makes Three, etc.)

Conversation Starters

"What kinds of things do families do together in this book? Do those sound like things your family does?"
"The boy's parents got divorced. Do you know anyone whose parents live in different houses?"
"Why do you think some people thought this book shouldn't be in libraries?"
"What makes a family a family?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic