Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

Where to Watch

Loading streaming options...

Screenwise Verdict

Let's be real: this movie is not good. With a 13% critic score and a 4.8/10 on IMDb, Confessions of a Teenage Drama Queen was panned on arrival and hasn't aged into cult classic status—it's just aged badly.

It's perfectly safe—no content concerns whatsoever, standard Disney Channel fare about school plays and popularity contests. But safe doesn't mean watchable. The protagonist is grating even by 'intentionally dramatic teen' standards, the humor falls flat, and the whole thing feels like a time capsule from 2004 that nobody asked to open.

If your tween is curious about early Lindsay Lohan or loves theatrical drama club settings, fine, it won't hurt them. But there are so many better teen movies (including Lohan's own Mean Girls from the same year) that this one is hard to recommend unless you're specifically mining Disney+ for nostalgia or have exhausted literally everything else.

The WISE score reflects reality: it's safe and mildly wholesome, but it's not imaginative, not enriching, and frankly not entertaining enough in 2025 to justify the runtime.

Age Fit

Common Sense Media pegs this at 11+, which feels right for the tween crowd dealing with school social dynamics. That said, it's so dated and critically panned that even nostalgic parents might struggle to sit through it. Best for 10-13 year olds who are specifically into early 2000s teen movies or Lindsay Lohan completists.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

58

Features typical teen rivalry and drama with Lola vs. Carla dynamics. The protagonist is self-absorbed and melodramatic (it's the point), which doesn't model great cooperation or emotional maturity. However, there's no malicious content and the conflict is standard school-social territory. Pacing is fine for a Disney teen movie.

Imaginative

42

The premise of a drama-obsessed teen who exaggerates everything has some creative potential, but execution is formulaic early-2000s Disney fare. No real invitation to build, explore, or express creativity beyond the standard 'be yourself' messaging. Theater setting offers mild imaginative context but isn't deeply explored.

Safe

82

Very safe for the target demographic. Common Sense Media rates it 11+, MPAA would likely be PG. No violence, gore, sexual content, or trauma. Standard teen social drama with rivalry but nothing toxic or triggering. Typical Disney Channel-style content from the era.

Enriching

38

Limited enrichment value. Basic 'be yourself' and 'don't let popularity define you' themes are present but handled superficially. No real skill-building, minimal cognitive challenge, and the protagonist's self-centered worldview isn't deeply examined. Entertainment value exists but it's low-stakes fluff even for its era.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Completely safe for tweens—no content concerns, just standard school rivalry stuff
Theater/drama club setting might resonate with kids interested in performing arts
Nostalgic curiosity factor if your kid is into early 2000s Lindsay Lohan era
Short enough that if they hate it, it's over quickly

⚠

What to Watch For

The protagonist is intentionally self-centered and dramatic—some kids might find her annoying rather than endearing
Early 2000s fashion and cultural references feel ancient to modern tweens
Critics savaged this (13% on Rotten Tomatoes) and audiences weren't much kinder—it's genuinely not great
Your kid will probably get bored unless they're deeply into nostalgic Disney Channel vibes

Conversation Starters

"Lola exaggerates everything—do you know anyone like that? How do you think it affects her friendships?"
"The movie is about wanting to be popular vs. being yourself. Do you think those things have to be opposites?"
"Carla and Lola are rivals over pretty small stuff. What makes a rivalry turn into actual bullying?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic