Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
This is a picture book that does exactly what it sets out to do: help little kids feel seen when they're worried about fitting in. The teasing is realistic but not mean-spirited, and the resolution is sweet without being saccharine.
It's been a classroom favorite for 30+ years because it works—teachers use it to kick off conversations about kindness, and kids genuinely connect with Chrysanthemum's emotional journey. The illustrations are lovely, the pacing is gentle, and the message lands without being preachy.
Is it groundbreaking? No. But it's a solid, comforting, useful book that belongs on the shelf of any family with early elementary kids. It's the kind of story you read together, talk about, and then reference later when your kid comes home upset about something a classmate said.
Age Fit
Best for ages 3–8, especially kindergarten through second grade. It's a perfect back-to-school read when kids are navigating new social dynamics and figuring out where they fit. Older kids might find it too simple, but it's a solid choice for early elementary.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
92
Models emotional resilience, self-acceptance, and empathy in age-appropriate ways. Addresses teasing and hurt feelings honestly without being preachy. The resolution—where a beloved teacher shares that she also has a flower name—feels organic and teaches that differences can become strengths. Pacing is gentle and reassuring.
Imaginative
75
Kevin Henkes's illustrations are charming and expressive, with anthropomorphic mice that convey emotion beautifully. The concept of loving your name and then questioning it is relatable but not groundbreaking. It's more about emotional insight than world-building or creative play. The sing-song text has rhythm that invites read-aloud engagement, but it doesn't spark extended imaginative scenarios the way fantasy or adventure stories might.
Safe
98
Completely safe for young readers. The teasing depicted is realistic but mild—no cruelty, no violence, no scary imagery. The emotional stakes are relatable (feeling embarrassed at school) without being traumatic. No content warnings needed. The only reason it's not 100 is that some sensitive kids might feel the teasing scenes acutely, but that's part of the book's purpose.
Enriching
88
Excellent vehicle for discussing names, identity, empathy, and how to handle teasing. It's been used in classrooms for decades as a first-week-of-school icebreaker. Kids learn that everyone's name has meaning and that differences should be celebrated. The book builds social-emotional skills and self-esteem. It's genuinely useful and has staying power—over a million copies sold, ALA Notable Book designation—but it's not going to teach critical thinking or complex problem-solving.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
Tackles teasing and self-esteem in a way that feels real but not heavy-handed—kids will recognize the sting of being made fun of
The illustrations are adorable and expressive; Henkes nails the body language of a kid wilting under peer pressure
Perfect read-aloud rhythm—the text practically begs to be read out loud with dramatic flair
Great conversation starter about names, identity, and what makes each person special
Sold over a million copies and is an ALA Notable Book—it's a classroom staple for good reason
⚠
What to Watch For
Some sensitive kids might feel the teasing scenes acutely, even though they're mild—be ready to pause and talk it through
The resolution is a bit coincidental (the cool teacher also has a flower name!), but that's picture-book logic and kids won't care
It's a 1991 book (this 2020 listing is likely a reprint), so the vibe is gentle and earnest in a way that feels slightly old-school—but it still works
Conversation Starters
"How do you think Chrysanthemum felt when the other kids teased her? Have you ever felt that way?"
"What do you love about your name? Do you know why your parents chose it?"
"If you could pick any name for yourself, what would it be? Would it be a flower, an animal, something else?"
"What could Victoria and Jo have done differently to be kinder to Chrysanthemum?"
