Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

Where to Watch

Loading streaming options...

Screenwise Verdict

This is one of the better Marvel origin stories, and it holds up surprisingly well 14 years later. Chris Evans nails the earnest, aw-shucks heroism without making it feel corny, and the WWII setting gives it enough visual and tonal distinction that it doesn't feel like just another superhero movie.

The violence is exactly what you'd expect from a PG-13 Marvel film—lots of action, but nothing gratuitous or nightmare-inducing. Common Sense's 11+ rating feels about right, maybe even slightly conservative for kids who've seen other MCU films.

What makes this work is that Steve Rogers is a genuinely good role model. He's brave, loyal, and willing to sacrifice himself for others—not because of his powers, but because that's who he is. In an era of increasingly cynical and snarky superheroes, Cap's sincerity is refreshing.

The movie does feel a touch slower and more old-fashioned compared to modern Marvel fare, but that's part of its charm. It's not trying to be Guardians of the Galaxy. It's a straightforward hero's journey with clear stakes and genuine heart. Solid family viewing for tweens and up.

Age Fit

Best for kids 10+ who can handle Marvel-level action violence and are ready for more serious superhero stories. The WWII setting and earnest tone might feel a bit slow for younger kids used to faster-paced modern superhero films, but it's a solid pick for tweens and up who want heroes with actual character development.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

78

Solid moral foundation with Steve Rogers embodying classic virtues like courage, selflessness, and standing up for the little guy. The tone is earnest without being preachy, and relationships are built on respect and loyalty. Loses a few points for some wartime violence and the occasional romantic subplot feeling dated, but overall models heroism and sacrifice in accessible ways.

Imaginative

72

The WWII-meets-superhero mashup is creative, with retro-futuristic HYDRA tech and the transformation sequence offering visual interest. However, it's more execution of an existing IP than truly original storytelling—it's a solid origin story but follows predictable beats. The period setting and alternate history elements add some imaginative flair, but it's not breaking new ground.

Safe

75

Typical Marvel action violence—soldiers shooting, explosions, people getting zapped by energy weapons—but minimal blood or gore. A couple of characters dissolve into light when hit by HYDRA weapons (which could be startling but isn't graphic). One brief scene shows a skinny Steve getting beaten up by bullies. The Red Skull's face reveal is mildly creepy. No sexual content beyond a couple of kisses. Common Sense Media rated it 11+, which tracks. It's exactly what you'd expect from a PG-13 superhero movie—no nasty surprises.

Enriching

68

Offers clear lessons about integrity, perseverance, and the importance of character over physical strength. The WWII setting provides some historical context (though heavily fictionalized). Steve's journey from underdog to hero is genuinely inspiring for kids learning about standing up for what's right. However, it's primarily entertainment—the ethical themes are present but not deeply explored, and the Nazi-adjacent villains are cartoonishly evil rather than nuanced.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Steve Rogers is genuinely likable—a hero because of his character, not his muscles, which is a refreshing message about inner strength
The WWII setting gives it a different vibe from other Marvel movies, with vintage aesthetics and a clear good-vs-evil framework that's easy for kids to follow
Action sequences are exciting without being overly intense—plenty of shield-throwing, motorcycle chases, and explosions that feel adventurous rather than traumatic
Strong supporting cast and solid humor that doesn't undercut the sincere heroism at the core
It's the rare superhero movie where the hero's defining trait is being a good person, not being snarky or brooding

⚠

What to Watch For

Wartime violence throughout—soldiers die (though not graphically), and there's frequent gunfire and explosions that might be intense for sensitive younger kids
The Red Skull's face transformation is briefly unsettling—his skin peels away to reveal a red skull underneath (it's quick but could freak out younger viewers)
A few mild language moments and some drinking in bar scenes, typical for a PG-13 film
The ending is bittersweet with Cap crashing the plane and waking up 70 years later—might need a conversation about sacrifice and loss

Conversation Starters

"Why do you think Dr. Erskine chose Steve even though he was small and weak? What made him special?"
"Steve kept trying to enlist even though he kept getting rejected. When have you kept trying at something that was really hard?"
"What would you do if you suddenly had superpowers like Captain America? How would you use them?"
"The movie shows how Steve stays the same person even after he gets strong. Do you think people change when they become more powerful or popular?"
"Why do you think the movie is set during World War II instead of modern times?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic

Captain America: The First Avenger