Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

Where to Play

Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased, but as an Amazon Associate, Screenwise earns an affiliate fee if you buy a book or game by clicking one of our links. We don't get any credit if you just Google it instead :)

Screenwise Verdict

Betrayal at House on the Hill is legitimately one of the most creative and replayable board games out there, especially if your family enjoys spooky themes and dramatic storytelling. The modular board and 50 different haunts mean you'll genuinely get a different experience every time, which is rare in board games.

The betrayal mechanic is the heart of the game—it creates real tension and excitement when one player suddenly switches sides. Most kids 12+ handle this well, especially if you frame it as part of the fun before you start. That said, if your kid tends to take competition personally or gets upset about "unfairness," you might want to wait a year or two.

The horror theme is more Scooby-Doo than actual scary—think monsters, haunted rooms, and supernatural events rather than gore or true terror. It's a perfect gateway for kids who are curious about spooky content but not ready for actual horror media.

Bottom line: If your family enjoys narrative-driven games and can handle a little friendly betrayal, this is a must-have. Just make sure everyone understands the traitor reveal is random and part of the game design, not a personal attack.

Age Fit

Best for ages 12-17 who enjoy spooky themes and can handle the social dynamics of a hidden traitor game. The manufacturer's 12+ rating is spot-on—younger kids might struggle with the reading comprehension required and the emotional complexity of the betrayal mechanic. Adults enjoy this too, making it a solid family game night choice for households with teens.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

68

The game features cooperative play that turns competitive when one player becomes the traitor, which can create tension but also teaches negotiation and adaptation. The horror theme includes haunted house elements, monsters, and betrayal mechanics that are thematic rather than graphic. The hidden traitor mechanic can occasionally create hurt feelings, but it's part of the game's design and most players understand this. The narrative-driven gameplay encourages storytelling and group engagement, though younger or sensitive kids might find the betrayal element emotionally challenging.

Imaginative

92

Exceptional creativity with 50 different haunts, modular board pieces that create a different house layout every game, and strong narrative gameplay where players literally explore an unknown haunted mansion. The game invites storytelling and role-playing as explorers discover rooms and encounter supernatural events. Each playthrough is unique due to the randomized room tiles and haunt selection, encouraging players to adapt strategies and embrace emergent narratives. The traitor mechanic adds dramatic tension and requires creative problem-solving from both sides.

Safe

82

As a board game, there are no privacy concerns, ads, or digital manipulation. The horror theme includes monsters and haunted house scenarios but artwork is stylized rather than graphic or gory. The betrayal mechanic can create social tension, but it's a core game feature that most players anticipate and enjoy. Parent reviews indicate it works well with kids who can handle mild horror themes. The 12+ age recommendation from the manufacturer is appropriate. The main safety consideration is ensuring players understand the betrayal is part of the game, not personal, which is standard for hidden traitor games.

Enriching

76

Develops strategic thinking, reading comprehension (cards and haunt scenarios), cooperation skills, and adaptability when the game shifts from cooperative to competitive. Players practice narrative thinking and improvisation as they explore and react to events. The game requires reading and interpreting complex scenarios, which builds literacy and critical thinking. The shifting alliances teach kids about perspective-taking and strategic deception in a game context. However, it's primarily entertainment-focused rather than explicitly educational, though the skills developed are valuable.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Insanely replayable with 50 different haunts and a modular board that creates a new mansion layout every time you play
Encourages storytelling and role-playing as your family explores creepy rooms and reacts to supernatural events together
The betrayal twist creates genuine dramatic tension and teaches kids to think strategically from different perspectives
Cooperative gameplay (before the betrayal) builds teamwork skills and gets everyone working toward a common goal
Perfect for kids who love spooky content but aren't ready for actual horror—think Goosebumps vibes, not The Shining

⚠

What to Watch For

The betrayal mechanic can sting for sensitive kids who take it personally—make sure everyone understands it's random and part of the game
Some haunts are more complex than others, and younger players (even at 12) might need help interpreting scenario rules
Games can run 60-90 minutes, which is long for some families—plan accordingly
The horror theme includes monsters, ghosts, and creepy scenarios that might be too much for kids who scare easily

Conversation Starters

"If you were exploring a haunted house for real, which room would you want to discover first?"
"How did it feel when the traitor was revealed? Were you surprised?"
"What would you do differently if you were the traitor next time?"
"Which haunt scenario was the creepiest or most interesting to you?"
"Do you think the explorers or the traitor had a better strategy this round?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic