Banana Split has a genuinely nice premise—what if instead of hating your ex's new girlfriend, you became best friends with her? It's a refreshing take on teen rom-coms that usually pit girls against each other. Critics appreciated it, giving it a solid 89%.

But here's the thing: audiences were way less impressed (59%), and that 30-point gap tells you something. It likely means the movie is well-intentioned and competently made but doesn't quite deliver the emotional punch or entertainment value it promises. The 6.2 IMDb rating and 3.1/5 Letterboxd score suggest it's... fine. Not bad, not great, just fine.

For families with older teens (16+), it's a decent option if you want something that models healthy female friendship and emotional intelligence. Just don't expect it to become anyone's favorite movie. It's the kind of film that's perfectly pleasant to watch once and then completely forget about.