Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
This is a lovely, gentle book that does exactly what it sets out to do: tell the true story of two male penguins who raised a baby together at the Central Park Zoo. It's not going to blow anyone's mind with literary brilliance or stunning artwork, but it's a solid tool for introducing young kids to the idea that families look different and that's perfectly normal.
The controversy around this book is way more interesting than the book itself, honestly. It's been challenged in libraries for years, which tells you everything about certain adults and nothing about the book's actual content—there's literally nothing objectionable unless you think penguins being good parents is somehow scandalous.
For families who want a simple, factual, sweet story about love and family, this delivers. For families looking for a page-turner or something wildly imaginative, look elsewhere. It's a teaching tool wrapped in penguin cuteness, and that's fine.
Age Fit
Perfect for ages 4-8 as a read-aloud that introduces family diversity and adoption in the gentlest possible way. Older elementary kids might find it a bit simple, but it's a solid choice for early readers tackling big concepts.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
92
Gentle, loving story about two penguins creating a family through nurturing and care. Models kindness, cooperation, and the zookeeper's supportive role. Emotionally healthy portrayal of love and family bonds without any chaotic or inappropriate elements.
Imaginative
68
Based on a true story with straightforward narrative and realistic illustrations. Invites curiosity about penguins and zoo life, but doesn't push creative boundaries or encourage much interactive play or building. It's sweet and factual rather than wildly inventive.
Safe
88
Extremely safe content with no violence, scary elements, or mature themes. The book has been frequently challenged in libraries due to its depiction of same-sex penguin parents, which some parents object to, but contains zero objectionable content for children. Appropriately gentle for young readers.
Enriching
85
Teaches about diverse family structures, adoption, and animal behavior through a real-world example. Builds empathy and understanding that families come in different forms. Strong emotional and ethical growth opportunity, though entertainment value is modest—it's a picture book with a simple, heartwarming message.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
Based on an actual true story from NYC's Central Park Zoo, which makes it both educational and heartwarming
Normalizes diverse family structures (same-sex parents, adoption) in the most gentle, age-appropriate way possible
Teaches kids about penguin behavior and animal care at zoos
4.9 stars on Amazon with overwhelmingly positive parent reviews praising its gentle message
Perfect conversation starter about what makes a family—spoiler: it's love and care, not just biology
⚠
What to Watch For
This is one of the most frequently challenged books in American libraries—some parents object to the same-sex penguin relationship, so know your audience
It's a straightforward picture book from 2005, so don't expect flashy modern illustrations or interactive elements
The story is simple and sweet but not particularly exciting—it's more of a 'teaching moment' book than a thrilling bedtime read
Conversation Starters
"Roy and Silo loved each other and wanted to be parents. What are some different kinds of families you know?"
"The zookeeper helped Roy and Silo by giving them an egg to care for. How do you think that made them feel?"
"Tango was adopted by Roy and Silo. Do you know anyone who was adopted? What does adoption mean?"
"Why do you think some penguin parents might not be able to take care of their eggs?"