This is the real deal—a legitimately great graphic novel series that respects its young readers enough to go dark. The father's death isn't a throwaway plot device; it's the emotional engine of the story, and Emily's grief and determination feel authentic.

The art is gorgeous, the world-building is rich, and the pacing keeps you hooked. It's earned its spot as a #1 bestseller and the BONE comparisons are justified. That said, this isn't for everyone. If your kid gets nightmares from Coraline or struggles with stories about parent loss, this might be too much. But for kids ready for meatier fantasy with real stakes? This is exactly what middle-grade reading should be—challenging, beautiful, and impossible to put down.

The graphic novel format is a huge win for reluctant readers, and the series has staying power (9 books total). Just go in knowing this is dark fantasy, not light adventure.