Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

Where to Watch

Loading streaming options...

Screenwise Verdict

Here's the truth: this is an obscure 1972 Christmas special that even audiences at the time didn't love (that 3/10 TMDB rating tells the story). The premise is sweet—a mouse and dog team up to deliver a kid's letter to Santa—but the execution appears to have missed the mark five decades ago, and it certainly hasn't aged into charm.

The content itself is perfectly safe and wholesome, which is great. But 'safe and wholesome' doesn't mean 'worth watching.' The animation will look painfully dated to kids raised on modern standards, and the pacing will likely feel glacial. There are dozens of better Christmas specials from every era that would be more engaging.

Unless you're a completist collector of obscure holiday specials or doing academic research on 1970s animation, you can safely skip this one. Your kids won't be missing anything, and you'll save yourself 30 minutes of 'Are we done yet?' The fact that it's nearly impossible to find anywhere should tell you something about its cultural impact (or lack thereof).

Age Fit

Theoretically appropriate for ages 3-7, but realistically, modern kids in this age range will likely find it boring and unwatchable compared to contemporary options. The dated animation is a real barrier.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

78

A sweet premise about a mouse and dog working together to deliver a child's letter to Santa. Models cooperation and selflessness. The 30-minute runtime is age-appropriate for young viewers. However, the extremely dated animation style (1972) and pacing may feel slow by modern standards.

Imaginative

52

The concept of a mouse and dog adventure on Christmas Eve has some whimsy, but the execution appears fairly straightforward and predictable. The 'Disney's Lady and the Tramp' setting reference suggests derivative rather than original world-building. Limited evidence of creative spark beyond the basic rescue-Christmas premise.

Safe

88

Extremely safe content for young children—a gentle Christmas story with anthropomorphic animals on a mission. No violence, scary elements, or inappropriate content apparent from the synopsis. The simple plot about delivering a letter poses no safety concerns. Family/Animation genres support this assessment.

Enriching

48

Limited enrichment value beyond basic themes of helping others and Christmas spirit. The simple plot doesn't offer much cognitive challenge or meaningful takeaways. Entertainment value is questionable given the 1972 production quality and 30-minute length that likely feels padded. TMDB rating of 3/10 suggests even audiences found it lacking.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Genuinely wholesome Christmas message about helping others and saving the day
Short 30-minute runtime won't overstay its welcome (though it might feel long)
Safe for even the youngest viewers—no scary moments or concerning content
Models cooperation between unlikely friends (mouse and dog team-up)

⚠

What to Watch For

1972 animation quality will look extremely dated and potentially off-putting to modern kids
TMDB rating of 3/10 suggests this is genuinely not good, even accounting for age
May be so obscure and hard to find that it's not worth the effort
Likely to bore kids raised on Pixar and modern animation standards

Conversation Starters

"Why do you think Gumdrop wanted to help Timmy even though they'd never met?"
"What would you do if you found someone's important letter on the floor?"
"How do you think the mouse and dog became friends even though they're so different?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic

A Christmas Story