A Christmas Carol – WISE Score & Parent Review | Screenwise

A Christmas Carol

Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

movie1984

65%

WISE Score

100

Avg. Tomatometer

George C. Scott's Scrooge gets haunted into humanity in this earnest 1984 TV adaptation—morally rich but showing its age.

7.8/10

100%

7.5

→

A Christmas Carol

movie

PG, 1984

65%

WISE Score

100

Avg. Tomatometer

George C. Scott's Scrooge gets haunted into humanity in this earnest 1984 TV adaptation—morally rich but showing its age.

7.8

100%

7.5

Jump to

Also rated on

7.8/10

100%

7.5

View →

Where to Watch

Loading streaming options...

Where-to-watch data byJustWatch

Screenwise Verdict

Look, A Christmas Carol is a masterpiece of moral storytelling—Dickens wrote it to shake people awake about poverty and compassion, and it still works. This 1984 George C. Scott version is earnest, well-acted, and faithful to the source.

But let's be real: it's a 40-year-old TV movie. The pacing is theatrical, the production feels dated, and modern kids raised on Pixar and Marvel may struggle to stay engaged. The Ghost of Christmas Future is genuinely creepy (which is the point), and the themes of death, poverty, and Tiny Tim's illness are heavy.

If you're trying to introduce your kids to the classic story, this is a solid choice—but you might need to watch it with them, pause for context, and be ready for questions about why everything looks so old. There are more kid-friendly versions (Muppets, animated), but if you want the real deal with moral heft, this delivers. Just know you're asking for patience in a TikTok world.

Age Fit

Best for ages 8-14 who can handle some scary imagery and heavy themes, and who have the patience for older, slower-paced storytelling. Younger kids may find it boring or frightening; older teens will likely find it dated unless they're into classic adaptations.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

Classic redemption story centered on compassion, generosity, and transformation. Models kindness and the importance of caring for others. Scrooge's journey from bitter miser to caring human is emotionally healthy, though his initial cruelty and the poverty depicted can be heavy. Pacing is theatrical and deliberate rather than chaotic.

Imaginative

The three spirits visiting Scrooge offer fantastical elements—time travel through past, present, and future, ghostly apparitions, and supernatural storytelling. However, as a 1984 TV movie adaptation of a well-worn Victorian tale, it doesn't break new creative ground or invite much active participation. It's imaginative in concept but conventional in execution.

Safe

Generally family-friendly with no gore, nudity, or sex. However, the Ghost of Christmas Yet to Come sequence can be genuinely frightening for younger viewers (death imagery, Scrooge's grave, ominous atmosphere), and the depictions of Victorian poverty, illness (Tiny Tim), and Scrooge's initial cruelty add emotional weight. The scary moments are thematically justified but not entirely 'safe' for sensitive or very young children.

Enriching

One of literature's most enduring moral tales about empathy, social responsibility, and personal transformation. Offers rich discussion opportunities about generosity, redemption, consequences of selfishness, and caring for the vulnerable. Strong ethical lessons with meaningful takeaways. TMDB rating of 7.5 suggests audiences find it engaging and worthwhile.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Timeless story about empathy, generosity, and second chances that's been teaching kids (and adults) for 180+ years
Strong moral framework for discussing wealth inequality, compassion for the vulnerable, and personal responsibility
George C. Scott delivers a memorable Scrooge—gruff and genuinely transformed by the end
No modern distractions or flash—forces slower, more thoughtful viewing (if your kid can handle that)
Excellent springboard for conversations about Victorian history, Dickens, and why this story keeps getting remade

⚠

What to Watch For

The Ghost of Christmas Yet to Come sequence is legitimately spooky—dark robes, graveyards, Scrooge's own death—may frighten younger or sensitive kids
Themes of poverty, child illness (Tiny Tim's disability), and mortality are front and center—emotionally heavy stuff
1984 TV movie production values mean slower pacing, theatrical acting, and dated visuals that modern kids may find boring or hard to engage with
Scrooge is genuinely mean and cruel in the first act—his transformation is the point, but it can be uncomfortable to watch

Conversation Starters

"Why do you think Scrooge became so mean and obsessed with money in the first place?"
"If you could visit your own past, present, or future like Scrooge did, which would you choose and why?"
"What do you think about Tiny Tim and his family's situation? Why were they so poor when Scrooge was so rich?"
"Do you think people can really change like Scrooge did, or was it just because he got scared?"
"What would you do if you had as much money as Scrooge?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic