TL;DR
If your teen is asking for these games, they’ve moved past the "brain rot" phase of YouTube and Roblox and are looking for "prestige" gaming.
- The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt is essentially an R-rated HBO series you can play. It’s brilliant, but it contains graphic nudity, sex, and heavy moral themes. Best for ages 17+.
- Dark Souls III is a "git gud" gauntlet. It’s gothic, depressing, and punishingly difficult. There’s no "easy mode." It’s rated M for violence, but lacks the sexual content of Witcher. Best for ages 15+ (if they can handle the frustration).
Ask our chatbot for a comparison of RPGs for teens
So, your kid has graduated from building dirt huts in Minecraft and is now talking about "slaying griffins" or "linking the fire." You’ve probably seen the titles The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt and Dark Souls III popping up on their wishlists or in their search history.
These aren't just games; they are cultural touchstones in the gaming world. But for a parent, they represent two very different types of "Mature" content. One is a masterclass in storytelling that feels like a gritty novel, and the other is a test of willpower that might result in a broken controller if your kid has a short fuse.
Think of The Witcher 3 as the Game of Thrones of video games. You play as Geralt of Rivia, a monster-hunter-for-hire in a world that is falling apart due to war and supernatural threats.
It’s an open-world RPG (Role-Playing Game), meaning your kid can spend 100+ hours wandering around, taking side quests, and playing a card game called Gwent. It’s widely considered one of the best games ever made because the choices actually matter. If you save a village from a monster, you might find out later that the monster was actually protecting them from something worse. It’s deep, it’s complicated, and it’s very adult.
Why Kids (and Teens) Love It
By the time kids hit 15 or 16, they often want stories that don’t treat them like children. The Witcher 3 offers a massive, beautiful world and a protagonist who is undeniably "cool." If they’ve seen The Witcher (Netflix show), they already know the vibe. It feels like "grown-up" media.
If The Witcher is a novel, Dark Souls III is a heavy metal album cover come to life. It’s part of a genre called "Soulslike," named specifically after this series. The hallmark of these games is extreme difficulty.
In Dark Souls III, you are a nameless warrior in a dying, gothic world. The story isn't told through cutscenes or dialogue; it’s hidden in item descriptions and environmental clues. But the main draw is the combat. You will fight a boss, you will die, and you will see the words "YOU DIED" on the screen. Over and over. Until you learn the patterns and finally win.
Why Kids Love It
It’s a status symbol. Beating a Dark Souls game is a "core gamer" achievement. In a world of Fortnite where everything is bright and fast, Dark Souls is dark, slow, and requires intense focus. It’s the ultimate "challenge accepted" for a teenager.
When deciding if these are right for your house, you have to look at why they are rated M.
The Witcher 3: The "Content" Concern
- Nudity/Sex: This is the big one. There are multiple scenes of graphic nudity and "romance" (sex scenes) that are not blurred out. It’s not pornographic, but it’s definitely R-rated movie territory.
- Language: Characters swear like sailors.
- Violence: It’s bloody. You’re decapitating monsters and occasionally humans.
- Themes: It deals with racism, domestic abuse, and the horrors of war.
Dark Souls III: The "Frustration" Concern
- Violence: It’s very violent, with lots of blood, but it’s more "fantasy horror" than "realistic war."
- Nudity: Virtually none.
- Language: Very little.
- Difficulty: This is the real "safety" issue. If your kid struggles with emotional regulation or "rage-quitting," this game will test them. It is designed to make you feel hopeless before you succeed.
Check out our guide on gaming and emotional regulation
Ages 13-14: Proceed with Caution
At this age, about 25-30% of kids are already playing these games because they see their favorite streamers playing Elden Ring (the spiritual successor to Dark Souls).
- For Witcher: I’d probably say no, or at least wait. The sexual content is very front-and-center.
- For Dark Souls: If they are mature enough to handle losing a boss fight 50 times without throwing their controller, it’s probably fine, though the imagery is pretty creepy (think skeletons, rotting giants, and screaming ghosts).
Ages 15-16: The Sweet Spot
This is when most kids have the attention span for these longer experiences.
- For Witcher: This is a great time to talk about the moral choices Geralt makes. It’s a "teachable moment" game about the "lesser of two evils."
- For Dark Souls: It’s a lesson in persistence.
Ages 17+: Green Light
By this point, they’ve likely seen worse on TikTok. Both games are excellent pieces of media that are worth experiencing if they enjoy the genre.
The Time Sink
The Witcher 3 is a massive time commitment. You cannot "finish" this game in a weekend. We’re talking months of play. If your family has strict 1-hour-a-day rules, this game might actually be frustrating because you can spend an hour just managing your inventory and talking to NPCs without actually "doing" anything.
The "Rage" Factor
Dark Souls III can genuinely ruin a kid’s mood for the evening. If you hear screaming from the basement and a thud, they probably just lost 50,000 "souls" (the game's currency) to a random skeleton. It’s important to check in and make sure they know when to walk away.
Learn how to set up healthy gaming boundaries
If your kid wants the vibe of these games but isn't ready for the M-rated content, try these:
- The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild: The gold standard for open-world exploration. Rated E10+.
- Skyrim: It’s rated M, but it’s much "lighter" than the Witcher in terms of sexual content and gore. It’s the classic fantasy RPG.
- Hades: A "roguelike" that is difficult like Dark Souls but has a much more colorful, stylized art style and incredible writing. Rated T.
- Tunic: Looks like a cute fox game, but it’s secretly as hard and cryptic as Dark Souls. Great for younger kids who want a challenge.
If you decide to let them play The Witcher 3, just be aware that you might walk past the TV and see a scene that looks like it belongs in an adult movie. If that’s a dealbreaker for your household, you need to know that there is no "family filter" to turn that stuff off.
If you let them play Dark Souls III, be prepared for the "You Died" memes and a lot of brooding. It’s a lonely, quiet game. It doesn't have the social "hangout" vibe of Roblox or Fortnite. It’s a solitary mission.
These games are the "prestige cinema" of the gaming world. They aren't "brain rot"—they require strategy, patience, and high-level reading comprehension.
- Choose The Witcher 3 if your teen loves a good story and you're okay with them seeing R-rated content.
- Choose Dark Souls III if your teen wants a challenge and has the emotional maturity to handle failure.
- Watch a "Let's Play": Go to YouTube and search for "Witcher 3 opening 10 minutes" or "Dark Souls 3 first boss." You’ll know within 60 seconds if it's too much for your kid.
- Talk about "The Grind": Ask your kid why they want these games. Is it because their friends are playing? Or do they actually want a 100-hour commitment?
- Set the Timer: Because these games are so immersive, "just five more minutes" easily turns into two hours. Set clear expectations before they pick up the controller.