Here's what makes choosing a Dixit expansion tricky: they're all just cards. There's no gameplay difference between any of them. No new rules, no special mechanics, just more beautiful, weird, whimsical illustrations to inspire storytelling.

So the real question isn't "which expansion is best?" but rather "which art style will my family vibe with?" And that's both liberating and overwhelming.

If you have younger kids (ages 6-10), Mirrors is your best bet. According to parent and player reviews, it's the most child-friendly expansion with clearer, more accessible imagery. The cards are less abstract and easier for younger minds to connect with storytelling prompts.

The art style is colorful and fantastical without being too dark or confusing. This matters more than you might think—some Dixit expansions feature surreal, dreamlike artwork that can leave an 8-year-old staring blankly while everyone else is already guessing.

Want the best of everything? The Anniversary expansion is widely regarded as one of the strongest options because it features artwork from all the previous Dixit artists. You get variety within a single expansion, which means you're essentially sampling the whole Dixit universe.

This is perfect if you're not sure what art style your family will love, or if you have a mix of ages and want something that appeals to everyone from your 9-year-old to your teenager to yourself.

Memories is another solid choice that leans into nostalgic, storybook-style art. It's gentle, evocative, and works well for families who enjoy the quieter, more contemplative side of Dixit.

If your kids are Disney fans, there's also a Disney-themed Dixit that uses characters and scenes from Disney films. It's more literal than traditional Dixit (which some purists don't love), but for younger kids who need that extra scaffolding to understand the game, it can be a great entry point.

Since gameplay is identical across all expansions, here's my honest advice: look at the art. Seriously.

Go to BoardGameGeek or Google Images, search for each expansion name, and scroll through the card images with your kids. Which ones make them say "ooh!" or "that's so cool!"? That's your answer.

Some families love the dreamy, abstract cards. Others prefer clearer, more narrative-driven imagery. There's no wrong choice—it's purely about what sparks your family's imagination.

One BoardGameGeek guide suggests that if you're buying three sets, go with Stella + Disney Dixit + Memories or Mirrors. (Stella is a standalone spinoff that plays a bit differently but uses the same card concept—worth checking out if you want to mix things up.)

Here's a budget hack: sometimes buying another base game on sale is cheaper than buying an expansion. You get 84 new cards either way, plus you have extra player pieces and voting tokens. If you're hosting big family gatherings or want to play with more than six people, this can actually be a smart move.

Honestly? Not really. The quality is consistent across all Dixit expansions. The only "bad" choice would be buying an expansion with art your family finds boring or confusing. That's why the "look at the art first" advice is so crucial.

Some expansions lean darker or more surreal (like Dixit: Harmonies or Dixit: Revelations), which might not land with younger kids but could be perfect for teens and adults.

Start with one expansion that matches your family's taste in art. If you have younger kids, go with Mirrors. If you want maximum variety, grab Anniversary. If you're still not sure, literally just pick the one with the prettiest box art—you really can't go wrong.

The magic of Dixit isn't in the specific cards you have; it's in the conversations, laughter, and creative thinking they inspire. Any expansion will give you that. The goal is just to keep the game fresh so your family keeps coming back to the table.

And if you're still on the fence about whether Dixit itself is worth it? It absolutely is. It's one of those rare games that works equally well with a 7-year-old, a teenager, and grandma—and everyone actually enjoys it. That's worth every penny.