In 2026, "Caught Up" is a bit of a linguistic landmine because two very different, very adult things are trending under that name.

If your kid is asking about it, they likely saw a 60-second "storytime" clip on TikTok or a "books that made me scream" aesthetic video. They aren't looking for a deep dive into the nuances of a broken engagement; they’re chasing the algorithm.

Teens have always been drawn to adult media—it feels like a window into the "real world." But Caught Up (the show) doesn't offer a window into the real world as much as it offers a window into a soap opera. The drama is dialed to eleven.

For a 14-year-old, the idea of a "double life" is fascinating in a true-crime sort of way. But the show’s focus is on the emotional fallout of infidelity and the toxic cycles of "staying for the wrong reasons." It’s "messy" on purpose. While it’s not "dangerous," it’s often just boring for kids who haven't ever had to pay a mortgage or navigate a long-term adult commitment. They’re here for the "tea," but they’ll likely find the actual plot a slog.

The Liz Tomforde book is a different beast. BookTok has a habit of aestheticizing "spicy" novels so they look like cute rom-coms. The covers are often illustrated and bright, which can make a 13-year-old think it’s in the same vein as a YA novel.

It isn't. The Windy City series is written for adults. It contains explicit scenes that go way beyond the "fade to black" moments you’d find in a typical teen read. If your teen is a fast reader and grabs this thinking it’s a standard sports romance, they’re going to hit some very adult chapters very quickly.

If your kid is craving that "I can't believe they did that" relationship energy, there are plenty of options that hit the same emotional notes without the explicit adult content or the "secret second family" tropes.

This is the gold standard for teen relationship drama. It’s got the love triangles, the pining, and the "messy" emotional decisions, but it’s grounded in the actual experience of being a teenager. It deals with real grief and growing pains rather than the "fiancé with a secret life" melodrama.

If they want the "rivals-to-lovers" or "sports romance" vibe from the Tomforde books, this is the pivot. It’s about competitive chess (stay with me, it’s actually intense), it’s hilarious, and it’s written specifically for the YA audience. It has all the tension and "will-they-won't-they" energy without the explicit heat.

For the kid who likes the "pro-athlete" angle and the high-stakes drama of the BET+ show, All American is a much better fit. It handles class, race, and family secrets with a lot more nuance and is actually aimed at a high school audience.

If it’s the "uncovering secrets" and "double lives" part of the Caught Up show that hooked them, point them toward this. It’s a page-turner that actually rewards the reader for paying attention to the mystery, rather than just waiting for the next shouting match.

Get a personalized book list for your teen

The biggest friction point with Caught Up isn't the "bad influence" factor—it’s the normalization of toxicity.

Soapy dramas like the BET+ show thrive on characters making the worst possible decisions for the sake of the plot. If your teen is watching, the conversation isn't "you shouldn't see this," it's "why do you think she’s staying?" or "is this what a healthy relationship looks like to you?"

Turning the "mess" into a critique of the writing actually helps kids build a better radar for toxic behavior in real life. It moves them from passive consumers of drama to active critics of bad character choices.

Q: Is the Caught Up show on BET+ okay for a 13-year-old? It’s rated TV-MA for a reason. While it’s not graphic horror, the themes of infidelity, sexual situations, and intense emotional betrayal are written for an adult headspace. Most 13-year-olds will either be bored by the adult legal/financial drama or confused by the complex relationship dynamics.

Q: How "spicy" is the Caught Up book by Liz Tomforde? It’s very spicy. We’re talking explicit, multi-page sexual encounters. It’s a "steamy" romance novel intended for adults. If you’re looking for a sports romance for a teen, stick to the YA section.

Q: Why is my teen seeing Caught Up on their feed? The TikTok and Instagram algorithms don't distinguish between "Adult Romance" and "Teen Romance" very well. If your kid likes sports, "aesthetic" book covers, or drama clips, the algorithm will serve them Caught Up because it’s currently a high-engagement viral hit.

Q: Are there any "clean" versions of the show or book? No. The "mess" is the point of the brand. For the show, you’re better off looking at our best shows for kids list for something with a similar vibe but appropriate themes.

Caught Up is a "guilty pleasure" watch or read for adults, but it’s a "miss" for teens. The drama is too grown, the tropes are too toxic, and the "heat" is too high. If your kid is looking for a thrill, there are dozens of better ways to get it that actually involve characters they can relate to.