2020
WISE Score
Amazon
Starflight finally finds his tribe, but the NightWing 'secret' is more of a nightmare than a superpower.
4.8
4.8View →Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased, but as an Amazon Associate, Screenwise earns an affiliate fee if you buy a book or game by clicking one of our links. We don't get any credit if you just Google it instead :)
If your kid is into dragons, this is basically mandatory. The Dark Secret is the turning point where the Wings of Fire series stops being a simple adventure and starts dealing with much bigger, messier questions about power and ethics.
Don't let the 'graphic novel' tag fool you into thinking it's 'reading lite.' This is a dense, high-stakes story that hits all the right notes for kids who want to feel like they're reading something 'real' without the friction of a 300-page prose novel.
Perfect for the 8-12 crowd. It's sophisticated enough for middle schoolers but accessible enough for 3rd graders who are ready for a slightly darker story.
Strong themes of loyalty and standing up for what's right, though the setting—a volcanic wasteland where dragons are being experimented on—is intentionally grim.
The world-building of the NightWing kingdom is incredibly detailed, from the secret tunnels to the volcanic landscape and the unique dragon abilities.
Standard fantasy violence (claws, fire, venom) is visually depicted. The plot involves kidnapping and some mild 'mad scientist' vibes with dragon experimentation.
Excellent for building narrative comprehension and vocabulary. It tackles complex ethical dilemmas regarding tribe loyalty versus personal morality.
By book four, the Wings of Fire graphic novels have hit a serious stride. While the first three books focused on the more 'obvious' heroes, The Dark Secret centers on Starflight, the most intellectual and arguably the most anxious member of the Dragonets of Destiny. For the kid who feels more like a researcher than a warrior, this is the book where they see themselves represented as the hero.
From a literacy perspective, this is a prime example of the Reading Rope in action. While the text bubbles are easier to decode than a standard novel, the language comprehension required is high. Kids have to track political alliances, understand the nuances of the NightWings' deception, and interpret the emotional weight of Starflight’s isolation through Mike Holmes' expressive artwork.
It’s also worth noting that this specific installment is much 'grimier' than the previous ones. The NightWing kingdom is a dying volcanic island, and the depiction of the starving, desperate tribe adds a layer of survivalist tension that wasn't as present in the RainWing or SeaWing books. It’s a great pick for kids who are starting to outgrow 'kiddie' fantasy and want something with a bit more edge and consequence.
Get a personalized guide on any topic
