The Thing About Luck – WISE Score & Parent Review | Screenwise

The Thing About Luck

Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

book2014

84%

WISE Score

4.2

Amazon

A 12-year-old Japanese-American girl learns to make her own luck during wheat harvest season—warm, funny, and quietly powerful.

The Thing About Luck

book

2014

84%

WISE Score

4.2

Amazon

A 12-year-old Japanese-American girl learns to make her own luck during wheat harvest season—warm, funny, and quietly powerful.

4.2

Jump to

Also rated on

4.2

View →

Where to Read

Amazon

Barnes & Noble

Libby

Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased, but as an Amazon Associate, Screenwise earns an affiliate fee if you buy a book or game by clicking one of our links. We don't get any credit if you just Google it instead :)

Screenwise Verdict

This is a gem—the kind of middle grade book that sticks with you. Summer's voice is warm and funny, and Kadohata nails the complexity of being 12, caught between cultures, between childhood and growing up, between wanting to please your family and figuring out who you are.

It's not a flashy, plot-driven book. If your kid needs explosions or magic or mystery to stay engaged, this might be a tough sell. But if they're ready for a character-driven story with heart, this delivers. The wheat harvest setting is specific and fascinating, and the Japanese-American family dynamics are handled with nuance and authenticity.

The National Book Award and six starred reviews aren't for nothing—this is quality literature that also happens to be accessible and engaging. It's the kind of book that builds empathy and teaches resilience without feeling like homework.

Age Fit

Best for ages 9-14. The themes (family duty, cultural expectations, economic stress) and emotional complexity are perfect for upper elementary and middle schoolers who are starting to think about identity and responsibility. Younger kids might find it slow; older teens will have moved on.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

Summer's voice is warm, conversational, and likable. The book models intergenerational family bonds, perseverance through hardship, and taking responsibility. Summer navigates disappointment, cultural expectations, and family duty with humor and grace. The multigenerational dynamics are handled with authenticity—Obaachan is demanding and old-fashioned, but the story doesn't villainize her. Summer's frustration with her younger brother and her crush are age-appropriate and realistic.

Imaginative

The book offers a unique window into wheat harvesting culture and Japanese-American family life—not a setting you see often in middle grade fiction. Summer's perspective is fresh and specific. However, this is more of a slice-of-life, character-driven story than a wildly imaginative adventure. The creativity lies in voice and cultural texture rather than fantastical world-building or inventive plot twists.

Safe

This is a middle grade book with no content warnings. The conflicts are emotional and interpersonal—family stress, cultural clashes, worrying about money, navigating a crush. There's no violence, mature themes, or shocking content. The 'bad luck' involves things like illness, financial strain, and interpersonal disappointment—real-world problems handled at an age-appropriate level. Books like this are inherently safe.

Enriching

National Book Award winner by Newbery Medalist Cynthia Kadohata, with six starred reviews. The book tackles cultural identity, work ethic, family obligation, and agency in a nuanced way. Summer learns to 'make her own luck' rather than passively accepting circumstances. Readers gain insight into agricultural labor, Japanese-American immigrant experiences, and the complexities of honoring tradition while finding your own path. The story builds empathy for multiple generations and teaches resilience without being preachy.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

National Book Award winner with a likable, authentic voice—Summer's humor and frustration feel real
Offers a rare window into wheat harvesting culture and Japanese-American multigenerational family dynamics
Tackles big themes (cultural identity, family obligation, economic stress) at a perfectly middle-grade level
Teaches resilience and agency without being preachy—Summer has to figure out how to change her family's luck herself
By Newbery Medalist Cynthia Kadohata, who brings warmth and depth to every page

⚠

What to Watch For

This is a quiet, character-driven story—not a lot of action or plot twists, so it might not hook kids looking for fast-paced adventure
Obaachan is demanding and critical in ways that reflect old-fashioned Japanese expectations—some kids might find her frustrating
The family faces real economic stress and worry, which could resonate deeply or feel heavy depending on your kid's current situation

Conversation Starters

"Summer feels caught between her grandmother's expectations and what she thinks is right. Have you ever felt torn like that?"
"What do you think 'making your own luck' means? Can you really change your luck, or is some stuff just out of your control?"
"Summer has to help take care of her little brother and cover for her grandmother. When have you had to step up and take responsibility for something hard?"
"How do you think Summer's family's Japanese culture affects the way they handle problems? What's different or similar to how your family does things?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic