Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
This is what we call a "situational classic"—if you're expecting baby number two and have a toddler or preschooler, this book is gold. Mercer Mayer knows his audience, and Little Critter's matter-of-fact approach to big brotherhood is both reassuring and practical.
It's not going to win literary awards, and you won't be reading it for fun once the baby actually arrives. But in that specific window of time when your older kid is processing the upcoming change? It's a perfect, gentle conversation starter that models helpful behavior without being preachy.
The 4.8 Amazon rating tells you everything: parents who need this book find it genuinely useful. It's simple, it's sweet, it does the job. That's all it needs to be.
Age Fit
Best for ages 2-5, especially in the months leading up to a sibling's arrival. Once kids are past kindergarten, they're too old for this level of simplicity, and once the baby's been around for a year, the moment has passed.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
92
Classic Little Critter story that models positive sibling behavior—helping with diapers, rocking baby to sleep, pushing the stroller. Emotionally healthy approach to a major family transition with Mayer's signature gentle humor. Normalizes both the excitement and adjustment of becoming an older sibling without being saccharine.
Imaginative
68
Mercer Mayer's charming critter illustrations have personality and warmth, but this is a straightforward slice-of-life story about a real family experience. It's relatable rather than fantastical—no dragons or adventures here, just everyday moments with a new baby. The imaginative element comes from Mayer's visual world-building with his beloved critter characters.
Safe
98
Textbook safe. Zero concerning content—just a sweet family welcoming a new baby. No surprises, no scary moments, no mature themes. Perfect for the exact situation it's designed for: preparing or reassuring a young child about a new sibling.
Enriching
80
Serves a specific developmental purpose exceptionally well: helping young children process and prepare for a major life change. Builds empathy, models helpful behavior, and validates mixed feelings about sharing attention. The 4.8 Amazon rating suggests it genuinely helps families navigate this transition. Not groundbreaking literature, but meaningfully enriching for its target audience and moment.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
Does the job it's designed for: helps young kids process the arrival of a new sibling without drama or anxiety
Mercer Mayer's Little Critter is a familiar, comforting character for many families—300+ books means your kid probably already knows and trusts him
Models genuinely helpful behavior (diaper changes, stroller pushing, gentle rocking) rather than just abstract 'be nice' messages
Short, simple, and gets to the point—perfect for toddlers with limited attention spans who are about to have their world rocked
That 4.8 Amazon rating from actual parents suggests it works in practice, not just theory
⚠
What to Watch For
This is a tool, not a masterpiece—you'll read it 50 times in the weeks before baby arrives and then probably never again
Published in 2001, so some visual details might feel slightly dated (though critters are timeless)
If your kid already has major anxiety about the new baby, this gentle approach might not be enough on its own
Conversation Starters
"What do you think Little Critter's favorite part about being a big brother is? What do you think yours will be?"
"Which job do you want to help with when the baby comes—diaper changes, bottle holding, or something else?"
"Do you think Little Critter ever feels annoyed that the baby gets so much attention? How do you think you'll feel?"
