Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

Where to Read

Amazon

Barnes & Noble

Libby

Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased, but as an Amazon Associate, Screenwise earns an affiliate fee if you buy a book or game by clicking one of our links. We don't get any credit if you just Google it instead :)

Screenwise Verdict

The Bone Witch delivers what YA fantasy readers want: original worldbuilding, a protagonist with actual moral complexity, and atmospheric writing that earned legitimate critical praise. The Asian-inspired setting is refreshing, and the necromancy angle isn't just edgy window-dressing—it's central to themes of being feared for being different.

The dual timeline structure is either brilliant or frustrating depending on your kid's reading stamina. Some parents on Common Sense Media found it hard to follow; others loved the mystery it created. The dark fantasy elements are age-appropriate for teens but definitely skew mature middle-grade at the youngest.

This isn't a breezy beach read—it's dense, atmospheric, and ends on a cliffhanger that demands you read the whole trilogy. But for fantasy-loving teens who want something beyond the usual fare, this delivers both imagination and substance. Just know what you're signing up for: necromancy, moral ambiguity, and a protagonist who might be building an army for revenge.

Age Fit

Best for ages 12-15, especially readers who enjoy complex fantasy worldbuilding and don't mind darker themes. The necromancy and death elements require emotional maturity, and the dual timeline structure demands focus. Strong readers at 11 could handle it; beyond 15-16, many teens will have moved on to adult fantasy unless they're trilogy completionists.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

68

Coming-of-age story with themes of finding your place despite being different and ostracized. Tea's journey from naive child to headstrong teen shows growth and resilience. The mentor relationship provides positive guidance. However, the story deals with death, resurrection, and being feared by your community—emotionally complex territory that requires maturity. Some drinking mentioned. The dual timeline structure can be disorienting, affecting pacing.

Imaginative

85

Original worldbuilding praised across multiple reviews. The concept of bone witches and necromancy is fresh, not derivative. Multicultural influences create a rich fantasy world inspired by Asian cultures (the 'Memoirs of a Geisha' comparison). Elemental magic system (ashas) layered with necromancy creates depth. The dual narrative structure—present-day Tea gathering a daeva army contrasted with her origin story—is ambitious. Publishers Weekly gave it a starred review for 'sweeping worldbuilding' and 'magnificent' balance of intimate narrative with epic scope.

Safe

72

As a YA fantasy book, it's safe in the traditional sense—no explicit content, no interactive dangers. The necromancy and death themes are handled within genre expectations. Common Sense Media parent reviews suggest ages 12-13 as appropriate. Some drinking is mentioned. The dark fantasy elements (raising the dead, being feared and ostracized, sinister curses) are thematically heavy but not graphic or shocking for the YA audience. The main concern is emotional intensity rather than inappropriate content.

Enriching

76

Explores themes of being different and ostracized, finding mentorship and community, the moral ambiguity of power (Tea gathering an army—'whether she is in the right remains a question unanswered'). The multicultural worldbuilding exposes readers to non-Western fantasy traditions. Complex narrative structure challenges readers. Coming-of-age elements provide emotional growth opportunities. The book raises questions about the cost of resurrection and the price of power. However, as the first in a trilogy ending on a cliffhanger, the full enrichment payoff is incomplete.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Original worldbuilding with multicultural influences that break from typical European fantasy
Complex protagonist who goes from naive to morally ambiguous—she's gathering an army and we're not sure if she's right
Dual narrative structure challenges readers while building mystery
Explores being feared and ostracized for being different, finding mentorship and belonging
Starred review from Publishers Weekly, strong critical reception for atmospheric writing

⚠

What to Watch For

Death and necromancy themes throughout—Tea raises her brother from the dead in the opening
Dual timeline jumps back and forth, which some readers find hard to follow
Dark fantasy tone with curses, fear, and moral ambiguity—not a light read
First in a trilogy with a cliffhanger ending, so commitment required
Some drinking mentioned; Common Sense Media parents suggest 12-13+

Conversation Starters

"If you had a power that made people fear you, how would you handle being ostracized by your community?"
"Tea is gathering an army and the book doesn't tell us if she's right or wrong—what do you think drives someone from being scared and alone to becoming potentially dangerous?"
"The book shows Tea's journey through two timelines—why do you think the author chose to show us both her past and her present at the same time?"
"What would you do if you could bring someone back from the dead but it came with a serious price?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic

Writing about The Bone Witch Rin Chupeco? Put this WISE score on your site