Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

Where to Play

Xbox

PlayStation

PC/Steam

Screenwise Verdict

Madden 24 is what it is: a hyper-realistic NFL simulator that will thrill football-obsessed kids and bore everyone else to tears. The strategic depth is real—play-calling, roster management, understanding defensive schemes—so there's legitimate learning here if your kid is into it.

But let's be honest: that 49/100 user rating is brutal. This suggests EA phoned it in with incremental updates, bugs, or the same-old-same-old that makes annual sports titles feel like expensive roster updates. If your kid already owns Madden 23, you might want to save your money.

The online component is the bigger parenting consideration. Football fans online can be... intense. Expect trash talk, rage-quitting, and the full spectrum of competitive gaming toxicity. If your kid can't handle losing to a 12-year-old who then tells them their team is garbage, maybe stick to franchise mode.

Bottom line: This is a niche product for NFL fans. It's not harmful, but it's not particularly enriching either unless your kid is genuinely passionate about football strategy. And even then, this year's version seems to have disappointed the community.

Age Fit

Best for ages 10-17 who already have genuine interest in NFL football. Younger kids will struggle with the complexity; older teens may move on to more varied gaming experiences or actual fantasy football.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

72

Sports simulation that models teamwork and strategic thinking. Football inherently involves physical contact but in a competitive sports context. No toxic behavior modeled in single-player modes, though online multiplayer can introduce unsportsmanlike conduct from other players. Generally promotes understanding of plays, cooperation, and athletic competition.

Imaginative

45

Limited creative expression—you're executing NFL plays within established rules and rosters. Franchise mode offers some team management and strategic decisions, but this is fundamentally about simulation accuracy rather than imaginative play. The 'strategy' element involves play-calling and roster management, but within very rigid boundaries. Not a sandbox for creativity.

Safe

68

Sports violence is contextual and expected (tackles, hits), with no gore or graphic content. However, the game includes 'users interact' online features which can expose players to toxic behavior, trash talk, and unsportsmanlike conduct from strangers. No confirmed in-game purchases or loot boxes in the data provided, though EA Sports titles historically have Ultimate Team modes with card packs. Missing ESRB rating is a concern for full safety assessment.

Enriching

58

Teaches NFL rules, play strategies, team management, and sports tactics. Can build understanding of football fundamentals and strategic thinking. However, the IGDB rating of 49.9/100 suggests the game may be repetitive or not particularly well-executed. Limited skill transfer beyond football knowledge. More entertaining for existing NFL fans than broadly enriching.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Teaches real NFL strategy, play-calling, and team management—actual football IQ development
Franchise mode lets kids run a team, make trades, and think long-term about roster building
Can spark deeper interest in understanding the actual sport and appreciating athletic strategy
Couch co-op can be a bonding experience for football-loving families

⚠

What to Watch For

Online play can get toxic fast—NFL fans online aren't known for their gentle sportsmanship
The 49/100 user rating suggests this iteration may be buggy, repetitive, or not a significant improvement over previous years
EA Sports titles often include Ultimate Team modes with card-pack mechanics that can feel like gambling (data here says no loot boxes, but verify in-game)
Can be genuinely boring for kids who aren't already NFL fans—this isn't Mario Kart accessibility

Conversation Starters

"What's your favorite play to run? Why does it work against certain defenses?"
"If you were a real GM, what would you do differently with your favorite team?"
"Have you run into any annoying players online? How do you handle trash talk?"
"What's harder—calling the right play or executing it with good timing?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic

Madden NFL 24