Isn't It Romantic

Isn't It Romantic

movie

PG-13, 2019

WISE
62%

WISE Score

70

Avg. Tomatometer

A rom-com cynic gets trapped inside a rom-com and learns to love herself—meta concept, mixed execution, decent message.

IMDb5.9
RT Critics70%
MC60
Common Sense Media
Where to Watch
Loading streaming options...
Screenwise Verdict

Look, this is a perfectly fine Netflix-and-chill movie if you're 14 and want something light that makes fun of cheesy romance movies while still being one. The concept is clever—woman who hates rom-coms gets knocked out and wakes up as the star of one—and the self-love message is solid.

But here's the thing: the gap between critic scores (70%) and audience scores (51%) tells you everything. It's a movie that works better on paper than on screen. Rebel Wilson is charming, the satire has moments, but it never quite commits to being either a full parody or a genuine rom-com, so it ends up in this lukewarm middle ground.

For teens who are starting to think critically about media and genre conventions, there's value here. It's not going to change anyone's life, but it might spark a decent conversation about how movies manipulate us and why we fall for the same tropes over and over. The self-acceptance arc is genuinely nice.

Just don't expect anyone to remember it a week later. It's the cinematic equivalent of a decent snack—satisfies in the moment, gone from memory by dinner.

Age Fit

Best for teens 13+ who've watched enough rom-coms to get what's being satirized. Younger kids won't appreciate the meta-humor, and frankly, adults found it pretty forgettable based on the audience scores.

WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
68

A rom-com parody that ultimately celebrates self-love and friendship over romantic clichés. Models healthy self-acceptance and genuine relationships, though the cynical protagonist's journey includes some eye-rolling at traditional romance tropes before her arc completes. Tone is generally upbeat and positive without being saccharine.

Imaginative
72

Clever meta-concept of being trapped inside a romantic comedy with all its tropes turned up to eleven. The 'waking up in a different genre reality' premise is creative and self-aware, poking fun at rom-com conventions while still delivering them. Not groundbreaking cinema, but the satirical angle shows originality in a tired genre.

Safe
75

PG-13 territory with Common Sense Media rating it for 13+. Contains some mild sexual innuendo, brief strong language, and comedic situations involving romance/dating, but no graphic content. The mugging scene at the start could be briefly intense but isn't graphic. Generally predictable and safe for teens, though younger kids might not get the satirical humor anyway.

Enriching
58

The core message about self-love and not needing romantic validation to be complete is solid, and the satire of rom-com tropes could spark media literacy conversations. However, the execution is fairly surface-level—it's more entertainment than depth. Mixed audience reception (51% RT audience, 5.9 IMDb) suggests it doesn't fully land its themes. Decent takeaway, mediocre delivery.

Parent Info

Why It Might Be Great

  • Smart premise that satirizes romantic comedy clichés while still delivering some of them—could spark conversations about media tropes and genre conventions
  • Core message about self-love and not needing a relationship to be complete is genuinely positive, especially for teen girls navigating romance culture
  • Light, breezy watch that doesn't demand much but offers some laughs if you're in the mood for fluff with a wink
  • Rebel Wilson brings charm to a role that could've been one-note; she sells the journey from cynic to self-acceptance

What to Watch For

  • The audience scores tell the real story—this plays better as a concept than as a fully satisfying movie; many viewers found it forgettable
  • Some mild sexual humor and innuendo that's typical PG-13 fare; nothing shocking but worth noting for younger teens
  • The satire works best if your teen already understands rom-com tropes; otherwise the jokes might land flat
  • Brief mugging scene at the start that leads to her head injury/fantasy world transition

Conversation Starters

  • "What rom-com clichés did you notice the movie was making fun of? Do real relationships actually work like that?"
  • "The whole point is that Natalie learns to love herself first—do you think that's realistic or just another movie message?"
  • "If you woke up trapped in a movie genre, which one would you pick and why?"
  • "Why do you think critics liked this more than regular audiences did? What makes a parody actually work?"
Stills
Isn't It Romantic — still 1
Isn't It Romantic — still 2
Isn't It Romantic — still 3
Isn't It Romantic — still 4
Isn't It Romantic — still 5
Isn't It Romantic — still 6
Isn't It Romantic — still 7
Isn't It Romantic — still 8

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic