The Incredible Machine is legitimately brilliant educational design—a physics sandbox that taught a generation of '90s kids how pulleys and circuits work. The problem? It's 33 years old and looks it.

The core gameplay holds up: arranging random objects to trigger chain reactions is still satisfying, and the open-ended problem solving is exactly what we want kids doing. But the DOS-era graphics, clunky mouse controls, and zero modern UI conveniences mean most kids will take one look and ask to play Minecraft instead.

If you've got a patient kid who loves engineering, tinkering, or puzzle games—and who doesn't need shiny graphics—this is a gem. But for most families, the spiritual successors (Crazy Machines, Contraption Maker) will be easier sells. This scores high on the WISE components but takes a hit for pure playability in 2025.