Fish in a Tree

Fish in a Tree

book

2017, Children's Books, Growing Up & Facts of Life

WISE
87%

WISE Score

4.7

Amazon

A dyslexic middle schooler finally gets a teacher who sees past her troublemaking disguise—and learns her brain isn't broken, just different.

Amazon4.7
Common Sense Media

Where to Read

Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased, but as an Amazon Associate, Screenwise earns an affiliate fee if you buy a book or game by clicking one of our links. We don't get any credit if you just Google it instead :)

Screenwise Verdict

This is one of those middle grade books that does everything right. It tackles dyslexia and learning differences with sensitivity and accuracy, never talking down to kids or turning Ally into an inspiration-porn character. She's messy, she makes mistakes, she acts out—and then she gets help and learns to advocate for herself.

The bullying is real and might sting, but it's handled well and serves the story. Mr. Daniels is the kind of teacher who changes lives, and the book shows how one caring adult can make all the difference. The friendship dynamics feel authentic to middle school.

What makes this truly enriching is that it works on multiple levels: it's a mirror for kids who struggle with reading or feel 'different,' it builds empathy in neurotypical kids, and it opens up important conversations about intelligence, learning, and self-worth. The Schneider Family Book Award and ALA Notable designation aren't just participation trophies—this book earned them.

It's not groundbreaking in plot or style, but it doesn't need to be. It's a solid, emotionally intelligent middle grade novel that will resonate with its target audience and actually help kids understand themselves and each other better. That's worth a lot.

Age Fit

Best for ages 8-14, right in the sweet spot for middle grade readers dealing with school struggles, friendship drama, and identity questions. Particularly valuable for kids with learning differences or those who need to understand their peers better. The realistic bullying and self-esteem struggles make it less appropriate for younger elementary kids.

WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
92

Emotionally healthy story about a middle schooler with dyslexia learning self-acceptance with help from a caring teacher. Models kindness, empathy, and friendship while addressing bullying realistically. The tone is uplifting without being preachy, showing genuine struggle and growth. Does include realistic bullying scenarios that may be upsetting but are handled thoughtfully.

Imaginative
75

The book invites readers to see the world through Ally's unique perspective and understand how different minds work. The title itself references Einstein's quote about judging a fish by its ability to climb a tree—encouraging creative thinking about intelligence. Includes 'The Sketchbook of Impossible Things' which adds a creative element. However, it's more character-driven than plot-inventive, focused on realistic contemporary issues rather than fantastical exploration.

Safe
88

Very safe content overall—no violence, sexual content, or inappropriate language. Common Sense Media user reviews note minimal language concerns (1/10) and realistic but upsetting bullying (1.5/10 for violence/scariness). The bullying scenes, while emotionally difficult, are age-appropriate and serve the story's purpose. No surprise traumatic content, though kids who have experienced learning differences or bullying may find certain scenes emotionally resonant.

Enriching
94

Exceptional educational and emotional value. Builds empathy for kids with learning differences, addresses dyslexia directly and destigmatizes it, and teaches about different types of intelligence. Winner of the Schneider Family Book Award (for books that embody disability experience), ALA Notable, and Global Read-Aloud Selection. Includes discussion questions. Helps kids understand that 'great minds don't always think alike.' Deeply meaningful for both kids with learning differences and their peers.

Parent Info
✓

Why It Might Be Great

  • Destigmatizes dyslexia and learning differences without being preachy—kids see that different doesn't mean dumb
  • Perfect mirror book for struggling readers and window book for their peers to build empathy
  • Shows a genuinely caring adult who makes a difference (Mr. Daniels is the teacher every kid deserves)
  • Addresses bullying, friendship drama, and self-esteem in realistic, age-appropriate ways
  • Award-winning (Schneider Family Book Award, ALA Notable) with a 4.7 Amazon rating—parents and educators love it
⚠

What to Watch For

  • Bullying scenes are realistic and may be upsetting for sensitive kids or those who've experienced similar treatment
  • The main character struggles significantly with self-worth early on—some kids may find this heavy
  • Best read with support available for discussion, especially for kids with learning differences who may see themselves in Ally

Conversation Starters

  • "Ally was really good at hiding that she couldn't read. Have you ever hidden something you were struggling with? What would have helped you feel safe asking for help?"
  • "Mr. Daniels saw Ally differently than other teachers did. Who's someone who really 'gets' you?"
  • "The book talks about how everyone's brain works differently. What's something your brain is really good at? What's harder for you?"
  • "Ally's friends stood up for her when she was being bullied. Have you ever had to decide whether to stand up for someone?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic