Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

Where to Read

Amazon

Barnes & Noble

Libby

Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased, but as an Amazon Associate, Screenwise earns an affiliate fee if you buy a book or game by clicking one of our links. We don't get any credit if you just Google it instead :)

Screenwise Verdict

Dav Pilkey is the patron saint of reluctant readers. If your kid groans at chapter books, hand them Dog Man or Captain Underpants and watch them disappear into a reading cocoon. Yes, the potty humor is relentless. Yes, you'll hear 'pee-pee poo-poo' at the dinner table. But Pilkey's books do something genuinely valuable: they make reading feel like play, not homework.

The graphic novel format—big illustrations, short text bursts, flip-o-rama pages—removes the intimidation factor for struggling readers. And the meta-narrative (kids creating comics about Dog Man) is a masterstroke: it doesn't just entertain, it invites kids to become creators themselves. Scholastic reports that Pilkey's books have been 'devoured by readers 7-100 years old,' and while that's marketing hyperbole, the core truth holds. These books build reading stamina, confidence, and a genuine love of storytelling.

The trade-off? The humor is juvenile. If your family has zero tolerance for bathroom jokes or cartoonish violence, these won't land. But if you can handle a little crudeness in service of literacy, Pilkey is a gift. Not every book needs to be Newbery-worthy. Sometimes the best book is the one your kid actually finishes.

Age Fit

Best for ages 6-10, especially reluctant readers who need high-energy visuals and humor to stay engaged. Younger kids (5-6) can enjoy these read-aloud if they can handle the potty jokes. By 11-12, most kids have moved on to meatier fare, though some will nostalgically revisit for the laughs.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

72

Pilkey's books (Captain Underpants, Dog Man, Cat Kid Comic Club) lean heavily on potty humor and cartoonish slapstick but consistently champion creativity, friendship, and the joy of reading. The humor is juvenile—lots of 'poo-poo' jokes and underwear gags—but it's never mean-spirited. Characters model resilience and self-expression, though the chaos and crude jokes won't appeal to every family. Emotionally safe, age-appropriate for the 6-10 crowd, but the relentless toilet humor can feel grating to adults.

Imaginative

88

Pilkey's graphic novels are creativity engines. The Dog Man and Cat Kid Comic Club series explicitly encourage kids to make their own comics, with flip-o-rama pages and 'how to draw' sections woven into the stories. The meta-narrative—kids creating comics about Dog Man—invites young readers to see themselves as authors and artists. The blend of visual storytelling, wordplay, and DIY comic-making is genuinely inventive and has inspired countless reluctant readers to pick up a pencil.

Safe

85

Books are inherently low-risk media. Pilkey's titles contain no graphic violence, no sexual content, no truly disturbing themes. The 'violence' is Looney Tunes-level cartoon bonking. Some parents flag the potty humor as 'crossing a line,' but it's predictable and harmless—no surprise triggers. The only caution: if your family has zero tolerance for bathroom jokes or exaggerated slapstick, preview a few pages first. Otherwise, these are solidly safe for elementary readers.

Enriching

78

Pilkey's superpower is getting kids who hate reading to devour books. The high-energy illustrations, short chapters, and laugh-out-loud humor build reading confidence and fluency, especially for reluctant or struggling readers. Beyond literacy, the books model empathy (characters learn from mistakes), celebrate creativity, and normalize being different. They're not deep literature, but they're a gateway drug to reading—and that's enriching in its own right. The DIY comic-making elements add genuine skill-building.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Proven track record of getting kids who 'hate reading' to beg for the next book in the series
Actively teaches comic-making skills and inspires kids to create their own stories
Fast-paced, visually engaging, and genuinely funny for the 6-10 set
Models friendship, creativity, and resilience beneath the fart jokes
Builds reading confidence with short chapters, big illustrations, and high-energy pacing

⚠

What to Watch For

Relentless potty humor—'poo-poo' jokes, underwear gags, and cartoon violence are the baseline
Some parents find the slapstick and crude language excessive; skim a few pages to gauge your tolerance
Not intellectually challenging literature, but that's kind of the point—it's a gateway, not a destination

Conversation Starters

"If you could create your own comic book character like Dog Man, what powers would they have?"
"What's the funniest part of this book? Why do you think the author made it so silly?"
"Do you think it's okay to make mistakes like the characters do? What did they learn?"
"Would you rather read a book with lots of pictures or mostly words? Why?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic

Writing about Dav Pilkey? Put this WISE score on your site