Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

Where to Watch

Loading streaming options...

Screenwise Verdict

Modern Times is objectively a masterpiece—98% on Rotten Tomatoes, a 96 on Metacritic, and rightfully celebrated as one of cinema's greatest achievements. Chaplin's physical comedy is genius, the social commentary still bites, and the artistry is undeniable.

But here's the thing: this is a silent film from 1936, and no amount of critical acclaim changes the fact that most modern kids will find it nearly impossible to engage with. The pacing is slow by today's standards, the lack of dialogue is a huge barrier, and the black-and-white aesthetic feels ancient to a generation raised on Marvel and Pixar.

If you're a film-loving family who wants to introduce classic cinema, or you have a particularly patient and curious kid, this can be a genuinely enriching experience. The factory sequence alone is worth showing—it's absurdist, funny, and visually stunning. But be honest with yourself: this isn't casual viewing. It's a project.

The WISE components are strong—wholesome, imaginative, safe, enriching—but the watchability penalty is real. Save this for a rainy afternoon when you're ready to pause, explain, and make it a teaching moment. Or just show the factory scene on YouTube and call it a win.

Age Fit

Common Sense Media suggests 6-8+, but realistically this works best for kids 9-12 who have the patience and context for silent cinema, or as a curated family experience with younger kids who are curious about film history. Teens and adults with an appreciation for classic cinema will find it rewarding.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

88

Modern Times showcases the Tramp's gentle kindness and resilience through physical comedy that never relies on cruelty. The film models compassion toward the downtrodden and celebrates human dignity in the face of dehumanizing forces. Mild depictions of poverty and brief drunkenness are handled with warmth rather than judgment. The emotional tone is uplifting despite touching on hardship.

Imaginative

94

Chaplin's visual storytelling is a masterclass in creative problem-solving and inventive comedy. The famous factory sequence—where the Tramp becomes a cog in the machine—is both absurdist and brilliant. The film invites viewers to see the world through a different lens, using pure visual language to communicate complex ideas about industrialization, freedom, and human connection without words.

Safe

85

Common Sense Media rates it 8+ (with some sources saying 6+). Contains mild slapstick violence, brief references to alcohol, and scenes depicting poverty that might need context for younger viewers. No profanity, graphic violence, or inappropriate content. The biggest 'safety' concern is emotional—some sequences of the Tramp struggling might feel heavy for sensitive kids—but it's all handled with Chaplin's signature lightness.

Enriching

91

This is cinema history that still resonates. Kids get to experience storytelling without dialogue, learning how body language and facial expressions communicate emotion. The social commentary on industrialization and workers' rights offers rich discussion material. It builds empathy for people facing economic hardship and celebrates resilience. Plus, the technical achievement—this is from 1936—is genuinely impressive and can spark curiosity about film history.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Teaches visual storytelling and emotional communication without words—a genuinely different way of experiencing narrative
The factory sequence is iconic for a reason: absurdist, inventive, and still funny nearly 90 years later
Opens conversations about workers' rights, the Great Depression, and human dignity in surprisingly accessible ways
Shows kids that entertainment looked radically different in their great-grandparents' era—builds historical perspective
Chaplin's physical comedy is legitimately impressive; the man was an athlete and artist rolled into one

⚠

What to Watch For

This is a silent film from 1936—no dialogue, black-and-white, different pacing. Most kids under 10 will struggle to stay engaged without significant parental scaffolding
Scenes of poverty and the Tramp's struggles might prompt questions about homelessness and economic hardship
Brief depictions of drunkenness (a millionaire character) and some slapstick violence that's mild but present
The runtime and slower pacing by modern standards mean this works best as a deliberate 'film education' moment, not casual Friday night viewing

Conversation Starters

"How did they tell the whole story without anyone talking? What did you notice about how the actors used their faces and bodies?"
"Why do you think the machines and factory made the Tramp go a little crazy? Have you ever felt overwhelmed by too much stuff happening at once?"
"The Tramp doesn't have much money or a home, but he still tries to help others. Why do you think he does that?"
"This movie is almost 90 years old! What's different about how movies are made now? What's the same?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic

Writing about Charlie Chaplin? Put this WISE score on your site