Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

Where to Watch

Loading streaming options...

Screenwise Verdict

Look, Buffy was revolutionary in 1997. It genuinely changed television, launched important conversations about female empowerment, and the writing holds up in many ways. The metaphor of high school as literal hell? Brilliant.

But let's be real: it's 2025, and this show is almost 30 years old. The special effects look like they were made in someone's garage (because they kind of were). The fashion is hilariously dated. The pacing feels slow by modern standards. And while the themes are still relevant, there are newer shows exploring similar territory with better production values and more contemporary perspectives.

If your teen is genuinely interested in TV history or you're watching it together as a nostalgia trip, great. The show has real merit for discussions about power, feminism, and growing up. But if you're looking for something to actually recommend to a modern teenager? There are better options that cover similar ground without requiring them to sit through 90s hair and demon costumes made of latex and hope.

The mature content is also significant—this isn't light viewing, and some episodes deal with heavy topics like sexual assault, depression, and death in ways that require emotional maturity.

Bottom line: Buffy deserves its place in TV history, but as a current recommendation for teens in 2025, it's a tough sell unless they're already into retro media or studying it for school.

Age Fit

Best for ages 15-16+ despite the 14+ rating, given the mature themes and content. Honestly though, this is more of a nostalgia watch for parents or a cultural studies assignment than something modern teens will naturally gravitate toward—the dated production makes it a tough sell.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

62

Models strong female leadership, friendship, and self-sacrifice, but includes teen relationship drama, betrayals, and darker emotional themes. The show deals with death, loss, and moral complexity in ways that aren't always 'feel-good.' Characters make mistakes and face real consequences, which is realistic but not always emotionally healthy viewing.

Imaginative

88

Groundbreaking for its time—used high school as a literal hellmouth metaphor, blended horror with comedy and drama in innovative ways, created rich mythology around vampires and demons. The show sparked countless discussions about symbolism and storytelling. However, the special effects and production values are very dated by 2025 standards, which impacts imaginative engagement for modern viewers.

Safe

45

Contains significant violence (staking vampires, demon fights), sexual content (especially in later seasons), mature themes including attempted sexual assault, character deaths, depression and suicide ideation, and dark magic addiction metaphors. Common Sense Media rates it 14+. Not something you'd want a younger kid stumbling into unexpectedly. The show earned its reputation for pushing boundaries on network TV.

Enriching

75

Excellent for discussions about power, responsibility, feminism, and growing up. The show is basically a masterclass in using genre fiction to explore real adolescent and young adult struggles. Strong character development and moral complexity. However, some of the gender politics and relationship dynamics feel dated by 2025 standards, and the show can be genuinely depressing at times.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Groundbreaking female protagonist who's both powerful and vulnerable—Buffy influenced a generation of strong female characters in TV
Smart writing that uses monsters as metaphors for real teen struggles (high school really IS hell)
Rich mythology and character development across seven seasons rewards invested viewers
Great for discussions about power, responsibility, friendship, and moral complexity
Cultural touchstone that defined 90s/early 2000s television—understanding Buffy helps understand modern TV

⚠

What to Watch For

Significant violence including staking, beheadings, and demon fights—it's horror-adjacent
Sexual content and relationship drama that intensifies in later seasons, including an attempted sexual assault scene
Character deaths and genuinely dark themes including depression, addiction metaphors, and suicide
The production values, special effects, and fashion are painfully dated—modern teens may struggle to take it seriously
Some relationship dynamics and gender politics haven't aged well by 2025 standards

Conversation Starters

"Why do you think the show uses monsters to represent real-life problems? What does the Master/Mayor/Big Bad represent?"
"How does Buffy handle the pressure of being 'chosen' for something she didn't ask for? What would you do?"
"Let's talk about how Buffy's relationships change throughout the series—which ones seem healthy vs. toxic?"
"The show is almost 30 years old now. What parts feel outdated and what still holds up?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic

Buffy the Vampire Slayer