Is the snowball accident in the book graphic or scary for sensitive kids?

It isn't visually graphic or gory, but the emotional impact is heavy. Mr. Terupt goes into a coma, and much of the second half focuses on the kids visiting him in the hospital and grappling with the fear that he might die.

What heavy themes or family background details are mentioned in the story?

Beside the accident, individual characters deal with significant backstories: Jeffrey's family is paralyzed by the past death of his brother, Anna's mother had her as a teenager resulting in family estrangement, and Danielle's family holds religious prejudices.

Is this book a good choice for reluctant readers?

Yes. The chapters are very short and cycle rapidly between seven distinct student voices, which keeps the pacing fast and prevents struggling readers from getting bogged down in long narrative blocks.

Do kids need to read the rest of the series after finishing this book?

This book stands completely on its own with a satisfying resolution. However, Rob Buyea wrote several sequels following the same group of kids through sixth grade, seventh grade, and beyond if your child falls in love with the characters.

Because of Mr. Terupt – WISE Score & Parent Review | Screenwise

Because of Mr. Terupt

Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

bookJuvenile Fiction

88%

WISE Score

Seven fifth graders tell their sides of a school year upended when a playground snowball fight leaves their beloved teacher in a coma.

Because of Mr. Terupt

book

Juvenile Fiction

88%

WISE Score

Seven fifth graders tell their sides of a school year upended when a playground snowball fight leaves their beloved teacher in a coma.

Jump to

Where to Read

Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.

Screenwise Verdict

If you want a middle-grade novel that genuinely moves kids without feeling preachy, Because of Mr. Terupt is a benchmark. Told through seven alternating student points of view, Rob Buyea constructs a believable fifth-grade ecosystem complete with cut-ups, bullies, brainy kids, and outcasts.

The emotional pivot comes when a chaotic winter snowball fight ends with Mr. Terupt taking a hit to the head and falling into a coma. The rest of the book deals directly with the fallout: guilt, self-reflection, and how kids hold each other up when adult safety nets break down.

It handles big topics—grief, family secrets, accountability—with respect for the reader's intelligence. Some of the student archetypes feel slightly broad at first, but the multi-POV structure pays off completely by the end.

Age Fit

Best for 9- to 13-year-olds (grades 4 through 7). The short chapters and relatable classroom setup invite younger readers, but the heavy emotional arc around medical trauma and personal guilt requires some emotional maturity.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

Models profound character growth, accountability, and kindness while treating real classroom issues with honesty.

Imaginative

Uses a compelling multi-narrator structure that builds strong perspective-taking, though anchored in a realistic school setting.

Safe

Deals with serious emotional trauma and a medical emergency, but remains completely free of explicit content or gratuitous violence.

Enriching

Delivers rare depth in perspective-taking, ethical responsibility, and emotional literacy for middle-grade readers.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Seven distinct voices teach kids how differently people process the exact same classroom drama and personal struggle.
Masterclass in empathy that tackles real middle-school issues like peer pressure, relational bullying, secret family grief, and self-advocacy.
Short, fast-paced chapters make it an ideal transition book for reluctant readers stepping up to longer chapter books.

⚠

What to Watch For

The coma plot twist hits hard halfway through when a snowball accident leaves Mr. Terupt unconscious in the hospital, driving heavy themes of guilt and responsibility.
Heavy backstory elements include a past sibling death, an estranged family following a teen pregnancy, and bitter exclusion dynamics among fifth-grade girls.

Conversation Starters

"Which of the seven students felt the most like someone in your own classroom?"
"Peter made a bad choice with the snowball, but was he the only one responsible for what happened?"
"How did Mr. Terupt handle discipline differently than other teachers you have had?"

Deep Dive

Why it resonates in the classroom

Rob Buyea was an elementary school teacher before writing this, and it shows on every page. He understands the quiet politics of a fifth-grade classroom: the way gossip spreads, how dynamics shift when a new kid arrives, and how quickly banter turns into bullying. Mr. Terupt isn't presented as a flawless saint, but as an adult who treats kids with dignity and lets them own their choices.

Structure that works for reluctant readers

The book's strength for this age group is its rhythm. Chapters are brief, sometimes just a page or two, and strictly labeled by character and month. A kid who normally gets bogged down in dense, single-narrator chapter books can fly through fifty pages because the viewpoint shifts constantly. It acts as an automatic engine for perspective-taking: you see Alexia being cruel from Jessica's point of view, then switch to Alexia's chapter and start to see why she acts out.

Navigating the dark turn

Parents should know the emotional temperature shifts dramatically in the second half. Up until the snowball incident, it feels like a spirited, hopeful school story. Once Mr. Terupt ends up in the ICU, the tone turns serious quickly. The characters confront heavy realities, including hospital visits, fear of death, and the crushing guilt Peter feels as the one who threw the ice-ball. If your kid is sensitive to medical trauma or sudden tragedy, reading this one together gives you a good space to talk through how accidents happen and how forgiveness works.

What Parents Ask

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic

Related Guides

Saving Mr. Terupt: Seventh Grade Drama and the Spin the Bottle Incident

A real-talk guide to the awkward social shifts, friendship fractures, and heavy family themes in the third book of the series.

Writing about Because of Mr. Terupt? Put this WISE score on your site