Is Mr. Terupt too sad for a 4th grader?

It definitely has sad moments, specifically when Mr. Terupt is injured. However, the tone is ultimately hopeful and focuses on recovery and friendship rather than despair. Most 9 or 10-year-olds can handle it, especially if you're available to chat about it.

What is the 'accident' exactly?

During a snowy recess, a student throws a snowball that accidentally hits Mr. Terupt in a specific way that triggers a previous underlying condition, leading to a coma. There is no 'villain'—it's a tragic mistake, which is a big part of the book's lesson on guilt.

Are there any 'bad' words or mature themes?

Language is very mild. Mature themes include a character's mother having been a teen parent and the social ostracization that comes with it, but it's handled delicately and is appropriate for the middle-grade audience.

Does my kid need to read the sequels?

Not necessarily. This book stands perfectly well on its own. If they fall in love with the characters, the sequels follow them into 6th grade and beyond, but the first book is the most 'essential' of the bunch.

Because of Mr. Terupt – WISE Score & Parent Review | Screenwise

Because of Mr. Terupt

Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

book

89%

WISE Score

Seven kids, one legendary teacher, and a snowball accident that changes everything—it's the ultimate middle-grade emotional rollercoaster.

Because of Mr. Terupt

book

89%

WISE Score

Seven kids, one legendary teacher, and a snowball accident that changes everything—it's the ultimate middle-grade emotional rollercoaster.

Jump to

Where to Read

Amazon

Barnes & Noble

Libby

Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased, but as an Amazon Associate, Screenwise earns an affiliate fee if you buy a book or game by clicking one of our links. We don't get any credit if you just Google it instead :)

Screenwise Verdict

If you're looking for a book that will actually make a 10-year-old feel something without being 'homework,' this is it. It’s essentially The Breakfast Club for the middle-school set, minus the 80s angst and plus a lot of heart.

It manages to be a 'message book' without the lecture. By rotating through seven different narrators, Rob Buyea ensures that every reader finds someone to latch onto. It’s fast-paced, occasionally funny, and genuinely moving. Just keep some tissues handy for the second half.

Age Fit

Perfect for the 9-12 crowd. It hits that sweet spot where kids are starting to notice social hierarchies and complex emotions but still need a story rooted in the familiar world of school.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

Models deep empathy, accountability, and the power of a supportive mentor. It handles complex social dynamics and family trauma with a remarkably healthy lens.

Imaginative

While a realistic school drama, the use of seven distinct narrators forces readers to constantly shift perspectives and imagine the world through someone else's eyes.

Safe

Very safe for the target age, though parents should be aware of a central, serious medical emergency involving a teacher in a coma.

Enriching

An absolute masterclass in perspective-taking. It tackles guilt, forgiveness, and the idea that everyone is carrying a hidden burden.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Multiple perspectives allow kids to see how the same event (like a classroom prank or a tragic accident) affects different people based on their home lives.
Relatable archetypes like the bully, the brain, and the shy girl are given actual depth instead of staying one-dimensional tropes.
Emotional intelligence is the core here; it teaches kids how to process guilt and how to support friends through genuine crisis.
High readability makes it a great pick for kids who usually find 'meaningful' books boring or slow.

⚠

What to Watch For

The central plot point is a snowball accident that leaves the teacher, Mr. Terupt, in a coma. It's intense and might be upsetting for kids sensitive to medical trauma.
Several characters deal with heavy home situations, including a father who left, a mother who was a teen parent, and a family grieving a deceased sibling.

Conversation Starters

"Which of the seven narrators do you think you'd be friends with in real life?"
"Do you think Peter should be blamed for what happened on the snowy field, or was it just a freak accident?"
"Why do you think Alexia feels like she has to be the 'queen bee' and pit her friends against each other?"
"What is something a teacher has done that actually made you feel seen or understood?"
"If you were in that class, how would you have handled the 'dollar word' challenge?"

Deep Dive

The Power of the POV

What makes Because of Mr. Terupt stand out in a crowded field of middle-grade school stories is its structure. We get the story in monthly installments from September to June, told through the eyes of seven very different students. You have Peter (the prankster), Jessica (the new girl), Luke (the brain), Alexia (the mean girl), Jeffrey (the slacker), Danielle (the shy girl), and Anna (the outcast).

This isn't just a gimmick. It’s a tool for building empathy. When Alexia is being a nightmare to her friends, we eventually see the insecurity driving it. When Jeffrey seems checked out, we learn about the family tragedy he’s carrying. For a kid in 4th or 5th grade, this is a revolutionary way to look at their own classmates.

Dealing with the Dark Stuff

The book doesn't shy away from the fact that life can be unfair. The accident that puts Mr. Terupt in the hospital is a gut-punch, and the way the kids handle the resulting guilt is handled with remarkable grace. It’s a great 'bridge' book for kids moving from lighter fare like Diary of a Wimpy Kid into more serious contemporary fiction.

If your kid devours this one, there are several sequels (Mr. Terupt Falls Again, Goodbye, Mr. Terupt), but the first remains the strongest. It’s a staple for a reason: it respects the emotional complexity of being ten years old.

What Parents Ask

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic