Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

Where to Watch

Loading streaming options...

Screenwise Verdict

Let's be real: this movie was controversial in 1992 and it hasn't aged into something more kid-friendly. McDonald's pulled their Happy Meal tie-in because parents were furious about the darkness.

Burton created something visually remarkable—the gothic Gotham, the twisted fairy tale aesthetic, Pfeiffer's iconic performance—but it's genuinely disturbing. The Penguin bites off a nose. There's a plot to drown children. Catwoman licks Batman's face in a way that made parents squirm in theaters.

For modern kids? It's a tough sell. The pacing is slow by today's standards, the tone is relentlessly bleak, and it lacks the quippy fun of MCU films they're used to. Film-obsessed teens might appreciate it as a cultural artifact, but most kids will find it boring AND creepy—the worst combination.

If you've got a teen who loves Tim Burton, gothic aesthetics, or wants to understand why this was such a big deal, go for it. But know what you're getting into: this is Batman as fever dream, not family entertainment.

Age Fit

Best for older teens (15+) who are genuinely interested in film history or Burton's work. Younger kids will be bored by the pacing and potentially disturbed by the content. This isn't family movie night material unless your family is really into gothic weirdness.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

35

Tim Burton's dark, gothic vision features emotionally disturbed villains, sexual innuendo between Batman and Catwoman, and a deeply cynical tone. The Penguin is portrayed as grotesque and violent, biting off a man's nose. Selina Kyle's transformation involves a nervous breakdown. The film models revenge and violence over cooperation, with minimal kindness or healthy emotional dynamics.

Imaginative

78

Burton's distinctive gothic aesthetic creates a visually striking, snow-covered Gotham with memorable production design. The reimagining of classic Batman villains is bold and creative, blending noir, horror, and comic book elements. The fantastical world invites visual wonder, though it's more about experiencing Burton's vision than interactive creativity.

Safe

28

Contains significant unexpected content for a PG-13 superhero movie: graphic violence (nose-biting, people burned alive), sexual content (Catwoman licking Batman's face, overt innuendo), body horror (Penguin's deformity, black blood from his mouth), and disturbing themes (attempted infanticide, child army plot). The Penguin's sewer-dwelling backstory and appearance are genuinely unsettling. Far darker than typical superhero fare.

Enriching

52

Offers some thematic depth around duality, identity, and societal outcasts. Catwoman's arc touches on empowerment and transformation, though through a problematic lens. The film explores corruption and manipulation in politics. However, the cynical worldview and lack of clear moral lessons limit its enriching value. More style than substance for developmental growth.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Iconic Tim Burton aesthetic that defined 90s dark superhero cinema—genuinely creative production design
Michelle Pfeiffer's Catwoman is legendary and explores complex themes of transformation and power
Danny DeVito's Penguin is memorably grotesque in a way that pushed boundaries for the genre
Could spark discussions about how superhero movies have evolved and what 'dark' meant in 1992
For film-interested teens, it's a cultural touchstone worth understanding

⚠

What to Watch For

Genuinely disturbing content: nose-biting, people burned alive, the Penguin's black blood and deformity
Sexual innuendo and content unusual for superhero films—Catwoman is overtly sexualized
Dark themes including attempted infanticide, using children as weapons, and pervasive cynicism
Slow pacing and 90s filmmaking style that modern kids raised on MCU will find boring
This is NOT a fun superhero romp—it's gothic horror in a Batman costume

Conversation Starters

"How is this Batman different from the ones you've seen in recent movies? Which style do you prefer?"
"The Penguin was rejected by society because of how he looks. How does that shape who he becomes?"
"Catwoman goes from being pushed around to being powerful. Is her transformation positive or concerning?"
"Why do you think superhero movies used to be so much darker and weirder than they are now?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic

Writing about Batman Returns? Put this WISE score on your site