Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
Amulet is the real deal—a beautifully illustrated, genuinely imaginative fantasy that doesn't talk down to kids. It opens heavy (dad's dead, mom's in mortal danger) and never lets up on the stakes, which is both its strength and its caution flag. This isn't a cozy bedtime read; it's an adventure that respects kids' ability to handle grief, fear, and responsibility.
The sibling dynamic is gold. Emily and Navin aren't bickering caricatures—they're a team navigating an impossible situation, and their bond deepens as the story unfolds. Kibuishi's art is moody and detailed, and the world he's built (robots! talking animals! mysterious magic!) feels original in a sea of derivative fantasy.
It's been a classroom staple and a bestseller for a reason: it hooks kids who don't usually read and gives them something meaty to chew on. Just know what you're getting—this is a story about loss and danger as much as it is about adventure. For most 8-12 year olds, that's exactly what makes it great.
Age Fit
Best for 8-12 year olds who can handle real emotional stakes (parental death, ongoing danger) wrapped in a fantasy adventure. The graphic novel format makes it accessible for reluctant readers, but sensitive younger kids might find the peril and grief overwhelming.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
78
Opens with parental death and features a mother in peril, which creates genuine emotional stakes but may be heavy for sensitive younger readers. The sibling bond between Emily and Navin is the emotional core—they work together, make sacrifices, and demonstrate loyalty. The pacing is brisk without being chaotic, and the tone balances adventure with real grief. Models cooperation and problem-solving under pressure, though the darkness of the setup (losing father, nearly losing mother) keeps it from being purely uplifting.
Imaginative
88
A genuinely inventive fantasy world with giant robots, talking animals, mysterious plants, and a magical amulet that grants powers. Kibuishi's worldbuilding is rich and visual—the graphic novel format showcases imaginative character designs and moody, detailed environments. The premise invites curiosity about how this underground world works and what the amulet can do. It's not derivative; it has its own voice and aesthetic. The series has sold millions and spawned fan art, cosplay, and deep reader engagement, suggesting it genuinely sparks imagination.
Safe
72
No sexual content, no profanity, no gore. However, it opens with the father's death (shown in a car accident scene) and features ongoing peril—tentacled monsters, life-threatening situations, and a mother who's been captured and is dying. The violence is fantasy-based and not gratuitous, but it's present and sustained. Web search results show parents asking about 'series trauma' on Reddit, with some noting it might be intense for 7-year-olds even though it's rated 8-12. The emotional weight and persistent danger mean it's not a book you hand to a sensitive 6-year-old without context. Safe for its target age, but not universally gentle.
Enriching
81
Deals with grief, loss, responsibility, and family bonds in a way that's accessible but not preachy. Emily must step into a leadership role and make hard choices; Navin grows from a younger sibling into a capable partner. The story builds problem-solving skills (navigating a strange world, deciphering the amulet's powers) and emotional resilience. The graphic novel format is a gateway for reluctant readers and builds visual literacy. Kirkus called it a 'must for all fantasy fans,' and it's been a classroom staple. It's not didactic, but it delivers meaningful themes about courage and sacrifice alongside the adventure.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
Gorgeous, moody graphic novel art that makes reluctant readers devour 192 pages in one sitting
Sibling relationship is the heart—Emily and Navin genuinely support and protect each other
Inventive fantasy world with talking foxes, stone guardians, and mysterious magic that feels fresh, not recycled
Tackles real grief (dad's death, mom in peril) without being manipulative or saccharine
#1 NYT bestseller that's been a gateway to reading for millions of kids
⚠
What to Watch For
Opens with father dying in a car accident—it's not graphic but it's sad and sets a heavier tone
Sustained peril and fantasy violence (monsters, life-threatening situations) throughout
Mom is captured and slowly dying, which creates real stakes but may worry sensitive kids
Some parents report it's intense for 7-year-olds; 8-9+ is the sweet spot
Conversation Starters
"Emily has to make some really tough choices to protect her family. What would you do if you were in her shoes?"
"The amulet gives Emily power, but it also seems kind of dangerous. Would you want that kind of magic?"
"Navin starts out as the little brother but becomes a real partner. How do you think he changes?"
"The book starts with something really sad—their dad dying. How do you think that affects Emily and Navin's choices?"
