Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
This is what modern middle grade fantasy should be—imaginative, emotionally resonant, and actually entertaining enough that kids want to keep reading. Amari Peters is a protagonist who faces real adversity (magical and social) without becoming a martyr or a superhero. The discrimination she faces for her 'illegal' talent is a smart parallel to real-world bias that gives kids language to talk about prejudice.
The world-building is genuinely fun—a secret Bureau where supernatural creatures work together, with summer tryouts and magical training that feels like Hogwarts meets the FBI. Parents should know there's magical peril throughout and some scary moments, but nothing traumatizing or graphic. The bigger emotional challenge is watching Amari be doubted and excluded, which can sting for kids who've been there.
This is a rare find: a book with substance that kids actually finish. The 4.7 Amazon rating and NYT bestseller status aren't flukes—this is engaging storytelling with meaningful themes about justice, family, and believing in yourself when the world doesn't. If your kid is ready for Harry Potter-level fantasy with more contemporary themes and better representation, this is it.
Age Fit
Perfect for middle graders 8-13 who love fantasy adventures with real stakes. The themes of discrimination and prejudice require enough emotional maturity to process, but that's exactly what makes it enriching. Probably too young for kids under 8, and most teens will age out unless they're devoted fantasy readers.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
88
Strong emotional core centered on family loyalty, sibling love, and perseverance. Amari faces bullying and discrimination but responds with determination rather than revenge. Models resilience, standing up for what's right, and believing in yourself when others doubt you. The protagonist's unwavering faith in her missing brother and her willingness to fight for him demonstrates healthy family bonds. Some scary moments and magical threats are age-appropriate tension, not gratuitous.
Imaginative
92
Wildly creative world-building that blends Men in Black-style secret organizations with supernatural creatures—magicians, fairies, aliens all working together in a hidden Bureau. The concept of a 'supernatural talent' being deemed illegal adds moral complexity. Fresh take on the chosen-one narrative with a Black girl protagonist navigating a magical world that doubts her. The briefcase discovery, summer tryouts, and hidden magical society invite readers to imagine themselves in Amari's shoes.
Safe
85
Age-appropriate middle grade fantasy with some magical peril and an 'evil magician' antagonist. Parent reviews note scary moments but nothing graphic or traumatizing. The 'illegal' magic element and themes of prejudice/discrimination require some emotional maturity but are handled thoughtfully. No gore, sexual content, or inappropriate language. The main concerns are magical violence typical of the genre and themes of being ostracized that sensitive kids might find upsetting. Multiple parent reviews confirm it's suitable for the target age range.
Enriching
87
Tackles meaningful themes of systemic prejudice, being judged for things beyond your control, and persevering despite intense scrutiny. Amari faces discrimination based on her 'illegal' talent—a clear parallel to real-world bias. Strong representation with #blackgirlmagic protagonist who succeeds through determination and intelligence, not just magical power. Explores grief, loss, and hope through Quinton's disappearance. Builds critical thinking about fairness and justice. Highly engaging storytelling (4.7 Amazon rating, NYT bestseller) keeps kids reading while delivering substance.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
Fresh, imaginative world where magicians, fairies, and aliens work together in a Men in Black-style organization that feels both familiar and totally new
Amari is a protagonist kids root for—smart, determined, and dealing with real prejudice when her supernatural talent is deemed 'illegal'
Tackles discrimination and systemic bias in ways that spark important conversations without feeling preachy or heavy-handed
Actually engaging—this is a NYT bestseller that kids voluntarily read under the covers with a flashlight, not one they abandon after chapter three
Strong representation with #blackgirlmagic at the center, showing a Black girl succeeding in a world designed to doubt her
⚠
What to Watch For
Some scary magical peril and an evil magician villain—nothing graphic, but sensitive kids might need reassurance during tense moments
Themes of being judged, ostracized, and labeled 'dangerous' for something you can't control can hit hard for kids who've experienced exclusion
The missing brother storyline involves grief and uncertainty that might be tough for kids dealing with loss or family separation
Lots of magic throughout—if your family has concerns about fantasy/supernatural content, this one leans all the way in
Conversation Starters
"Amari's talent is called 'illegal' even though she didn't choose it. Have you ever felt judged for something that wasn't your fault?"
"Why do you think the other kids at the Bureau are so quick to doubt Amari? What would you do if you were in her shoes?"
"Amari never stops believing her brother is alive, even when everyone tells her she's wrong. When is it important to trust your gut, and when should you listen to others?"
"If you got a mysterious briefcase with an invitation to a secret supernatural organization, would you go? What would scare you most about it?"
