Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

Where to Read

Amazon

Barnes & Noble

Libby

Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased, but as an Amazon Associate, Screenwise earns an affiliate fee if you buy a book or game by clicking one of our links. We don't get any credit if you just Google it instead :)

Screenwise Verdict

Look, this is a legitimate masterpiece of imaginative literature, and if your kid connects with it, it's magic. But let's be real: this book is weird, even by modern fantasy standards, and the Victorian pacing and humor mean plenty of kids will bounce off it hard.

The imagination score is off the charts—Carroll invented a world where nonsense operates by perfect internal logic, where wordplay becomes reality, where size and identity are fluid. It's the blueprint for so much fantasy that came after.

But it's also genuinely challenging. The humor is often mathematical or satirical in ways that fly over modern heads. The plot meanders. Some kids will find Alice's adventures delightful; others will be frustrated that nothing makes sense and there's no clear goal.

This 2024 Peter Pauper Press edition is gorgeous—embossed cover, quality paper, Tenniel's classic illustrations—so if you're building a home library, it's a solid pick. Just know that "classic" doesn't automatically mean "page-turner for every 8-year-old." Try it as a read-aloud first, gauge interest, and don't force it if it's not clicking.

Age Fit

Best for strong readers 8-10+ or as a read-aloud for ages 6+ with an adult who can navigate the weirdness together. The surreal logic and Victorian pacing mean this isn't for every kid—some will be enchanted, others will check out. Teens and adults can appreciate the wordplay and satire on another level.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

78

Carroll's classic models curiosity and resilience as Alice navigates absurd situations with politeness and determination. The tone is whimsical rather than mean-spirited, though some characters (the Queen of Hearts, the Caterpillar) can be rude or threatening in a Victorian-storybook way. No modern concerns about cruelty or toxicity, but the social dynamics are occasionally sharp.

Imaginative

96

This is the gold standard for imaginative literature—talking animals, logic puzzles disguised as nonsense, a world where size and rules shift constantly. Carroll invented a vocabulary of creative play (portmanteaus, riddles, poems) that has inspired generations of writers and artists. Pure imagination fuel.

Safe

88

Very safe by modern standards. No graphic content, no real violence (the Queen threatens beheadings but none occur), no mature themes. Some moments might briefly unsettle younger kids—Alice crying in a pool of her own tears, the Duchess being rough with a baby—but nothing traumatic. The surreal logic can confuse or frustrate some readers, but that's not a safety issue.

Enriching

82

Rich with wordplay, logic puzzles, and Victorian satire that rewards rereading at different ages. Builds vocabulary and tolerance for ambiguity. The nonsense poems and riddles encourage lateral thinking. That said, much of the humor is dated (Victorian social satire, mathematical in-jokes), and modern kids may miss layers without context. Still, it's a foundational text that opens doors to literary analysis and creative thinking.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Unmatched imagination: a world where nonsense follows its own perfect internal logic
Wordplay, riddles, and poems that reward rereading and build vocabulary
Alice models curiosity, politeness, and persistence through bizarre situations
Tenniel's iconic illustrations are part of the cultural DNA
A literary foundation that opens doors to understanding references across media

⚠

What to Watch For

Victorian pacing and humor—some kids will be bored, others enchanted
The surreal logic can frustrate literal-minded readers or younger kids who expect clear cause-and-effect
Some characters are rude or threatening in a storybook way (the Queen's beheading threats, the Duchess's roughness)
Best as a read-aloud for younger kids or for strong independent readers 9+

Conversation Starters

"If you could shrink or grow like Alice, what size would you want to be and why?"
"Which Wonderland character would you most want to have tea with? Which one would drive you crazy?"
"Why do you think the Cheshire Cat only appears in pieces? What would you do if you met a cat like that?"
"Alice keeps trying to remember poems and getting them wrong—has that ever happened to you when you're nervous?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic

Alice's Adventures in Wonderland