Released in 2020, Fatima is a dramatization of the "Miracle of the Sun" and the events leading up to it. Set in the middle of World War I, it follows 10-year-old Lúcia dos Santos and her two younger cousins, Francisco and Jacinta Marto. They claim to see visions of the Virgin Mary, who gives them messages of peace and some pretty terrifying "secrets."

This isn't your standard low-budget Sunday School cartoon. It’s a high-production-value film starring Harvey Keitel and Sônia Braga. It deals with the clash between the children’s faith, their parents' skepticism, and a secular government that is desperate to shut down the "superstition" before it starts a riot.

If you grew up in a religious household, you might remember the 1952 classic The Miracle of Our Lady of Fatima. That version is much more of a "family afternoon" vibe. The 2020 version, however, leans into the weight of the story.

We often think of religious media as "safe" or "soft," but Fatima is a reminder that history—especially religious history—is often gritty and complicated. For parents who want to move past "brain rot" content and engage with something that has actual substance, this movie is a great pick—but it requires some prep work.

The PG-13 rating usually signals "Marvel-style violence" or "a few F-bombs." In Fatima, the rating is about intensity and thematic elements.

Here is what you’re actually looking at:

There is a sequence where the children are shown a vision of hell. It’s not "cartoon fire and pitchforks." It’s visceral—think scorched earth, suffering souls, and a dark, oppressive atmosphere. For a sensitive 7-year-old, this is nightmare fuel. For a 12-year-old, it’s a striking piece of cinematography that sparks a conversation about justice and consequences.

The movie frequently cuts to the front lines of WWI. You see soldiers in trenches, explosions, and the general misery of war. While it’s not Saving Private Ryan levels of gore, it is realistic and somber. The town square scenes also involve the names of the dead being read aloud, which highlights the grief of the community.

One of the most stressful parts of the movie isn't the supernatural stuff—it’s the way the adults treat the kids. The local administrator (the "villain" of the piece) essentially kidnaps the children and threatens them with death (boiling oil) to get them to recant. While we know they’ll be okay, the tension in those scenes is high.

Check out our guide on how to handle scary themes in movies

Every kid is different, but here’s how I’d break it down based on community data and typical developmental stages:

Let’s be real: some faith-based movies are just... bad. They have cheesy acting and scripts that feel like a lecture. Fatima actually avoids most of those traps. The acting from the children is top-tier, and the cinematography of the Portuguese countryside is gorgeous.

However, the framing story (Harvey Keitel as a skeptical professor interviewing an elderly Lúcia in the 1980s) can feel a bit slow. It’s meant to provide a "modern" perspective, but it occasionally kills the momentum of the 1917 story. If your kids have a short attention span, they might start checking their Discord notifications during these scenes.

Learn more about managing teen phone distractions during family time

If you decide to do a family movie night with Fatima, here are a few conversation starters that aren't cringey:

If you realized halfway through this post that Fatima is a bit too heavy for your crew right now, check out these options:

Fatima (2020) is a rare bird: a faith-based movie that actually respects the intelligence of its audience. It doesn't shy away from the fact that being a "visionary" was actually kind of a nightmare for these kids.

If you have older kids or teens, it’s a 10/10 recommendation for a movie that actually sparks a real conversation. Just don't go in expecting a lighthearted miracle story—this is a war-time drama that happens to have a miracle at the end.

Ask our chatbot for more PG-13 movie recommendations for middle schoolers