Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

Where to Watch

Loading streaming options...

Screenwise Verdict

Let's be honest: West Side Story is a landmark of American musical theater, but watching it in 2025 is ROUGH.

The good: Bernstein's score is genuinely brilliant, the choreography is iconic, and the themes of racism and tribalism are evergreen. If you have a theater kid or a teen studying film history, this is required viewing. The tragic love story still packs an emotional punch.

The bad: It's nearly 3 hours of 1961 theatrical pacing that will feel glacial to modern viewers. The brownface casting—white actors playing Puerto Rican characters with makeup and accents—is deeply uncomfortable and requires historical context. The violence (two stabbings, a shooting, attempted sexual assault) means this isn't for younger kids.

The verdict: This is a "respect it more than enjoy it" situation for most families. If your teen is into musicals or studying classics, go for it—but maybe watch the 2021 Spielberg version instead, which fixes the casting issues and tightens the pacing. The 1961 version is important, but it's also kind of a slog.

Age Fit

Best for ages 12-16, especially teens studying theater, classic film, or American history. Adults who love musicals will appreciate it, but most modern kids will struggle with the dated pacing and theatrical style—this plays like a stage production on film, not a movie.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

68

A tragic love story with genuine emotional depth and themes of prejudice, but also gang violence, death, and attempted sexual assault (Anita's scene). The romance between Tony and Maria is tender and idealistic, but the surrounding world is harsh. Models both the destructive nature of hatred and the power of love, though the tragic ending undercuts the hopeful message.

Imaginative

82

Jerome Robbins' choreography is genuinely groundbreaking—turning street fights into ballet, making gang members leap and pirouette. Bernstein's score blends classical composition with Latin rhythms and jazz. The visual language of color-coded gangs and the stylized New York setting create a heightened theatrical world. It reimagines Romeo and Juliet in 1950s NYC, which was bold for 1961.

Safe

58

Violence includes knife fights, beatings, and two on-screen deaths (Riff and Bernardo stabbed, Tony shot). The attempted assault of Anita is intense and frightening. Ethnic slurs and prejudice are central to the plot. Some sexual references and Anita in undergarments during one scene. Common Sense Media rates it 11+, which feels right—this isn't a surprise-violence situation since it's a known tragedy, but younger kids would find it scary and upsetting.

Enriching

79

One of the most celebrated musicals in American cinema (92% RT critics, 86 Metacritic). Opens conversations about racism, immigration, tribalism, and how prejudice destroys lives. The Shakespeare connection adds literary weight. Bernstein's score is musically sophisticated. However, the 1961 portrayal of Puerto Ricans—with brownface casting and stereotypical accents—is deeply problematic and requires historical context for modern viewers.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

The choreography is genuinely stunning—gang members doing ballet during rumbles is iconic and weird and brilliant
Bernstein's score is legitimately great music education: "America," "Somewhere," "Tonight" are classics
Opens real conversations about racism, tribalism, and how prejudice kills—literally
For theater kids or teens studying film history, this is essential viewing
The tragic love story hits hard if you can get past the dated presentation

⚠

What to Watch For

Two stabbings and a shooting death—not graphic by modern standards but still intense
Anita's attempted assault scene is genuinely frightening and may need a heads-up
Brownface casting and stereotypical accents: white actors playing Puerto Rican characters with questionable makeup
Ethnic slurs throughout (that's the point, but still)
The 1961 pacing is SLOW—nearly 3 hours of theatrical staging that modern kids will find excruciating

Conversation Starters

"Why do you think the Jets and Sharks hate each other so much? Have you ever seen groups at school act like this?"
"The movie cast white actors in brownface to play Puerto Rican characters. Why is that a problem, and how would you cast it today?"
"Tony and Maria fall in love despite their friends being enemies. Do you think their love could have changed anything?"
"What did you think about how the movie shows racism and immigration? Does any of that feel familiar today?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic