We Are Marshall is a perfectly competent inspirational sports drama that does exactly what it says on the tin. It's earnest, emotional, and based on a genuinely moving true story about a college town devastated by tragedy.

The problem? It's also pretty formulaic. Critics gave it 48% on Rotten Tomatoes for a reason—it hits every expected beat of the genre without much innovation. Matthew McConaughey does his Matthew McConaughey thing, the underdog team struggles then perseveres, the music swells at the right moments. You've seen this movie before, just with different jerseys.

That said, audiences liked it (79%), and there's real value in the true story it tells. The 1970 Marshall plane crash was a devastating event, and the film respectfully shows how a community processed grief and found meaning in rebuilding. Those are genuinely enriching themes.

The challenge for modern kids: it's nearly 20 years old, feels very 2000s, and runs over 2 hours. Unless your kid is already into sports movies or true stories, this might be a tough sell. It's not bad, just... fine. And "fine" doesn't usually cut it when competing with everything else available.

If you've got a sports-loving kid interested in real history and you're okay preparing them for heavy grief content, go for it. Otherwise, there are more engaging ways to teach resilience.