Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

Where to Read

Amazon

Barnes & Noble

Libby

Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased, but as an Amazon Associate, Screenwise earns an affiliate fee if you buy a book or game by clicking one of our links. We don't get any credit if you just Google it instead :)

Screenwise Verdict

Look, Colleen Hoover knows how to write a page-turner. Ugly Love will make you feel things—mostly frustration at watching Tate accept emotional breadcrumbs from a man who won't even let her ask questions. The dual timeline is clever, and when the Big Secret drops, it's devastating.

But let's be real: this is not a healthy relationship model. Miles controls everything, Tate waits and hopes, and the book frames this as romantic rather than red-flag territory. The explicit sex scenes are plentiful (parent forums call this 'one of her smuttier books'), and the emotional manipulation is intense.

For adult readers who enjoy angsty, dramatic romance and can recognize the toxicity for what it is? Fine. But this absolutely should not be in the hands of teens, despite how many high schoolers are reading Hoover. The 4.6 Amazon rating reflects its popularity, not its wholesomeness. This is a guilty pleasure read at best, and at worst, it's romanticizing dynamics that would be dealbreakers in real life.

Age Fit

This is adult romance for readers 18 and up. The explicit sexual content, toxic relationship dynamics, and heavy trauma themes make it inappropriate for teens, despite Hoover's popularity with younger readers.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

35

This is a toxic relationship story disguised as romance. Miles enforces rigid rules ('no questions, no future'), and Tate accepts a dynamic where she's emotionally sidelined while he works through trauma. The 'no strings' arrangement isn't mutual empowerment—it's him controlling the terms while she hopes for more. The emotional arc centers on pain, secrecy, and a woman trying to fix a broken man. Not a healthy model for relationships.

Imaginative

42

Hoover writes with emotional intensity and uses dual timelines (present-day chapters alternate with Miles's past in verse), which is structurally interesting. But the story is formulaic contemporary romance: brooding damaged man, woman who thinks she can heal him, big secret reveal. The 'dark past' trope is well-worn, and there's little here that breaks new ground in either character dynamics or storytelling.

Safe

25

Multiple sources confirm this is 'one of her smuttier books' with 'very heavy on sex.' Explicit sexual content throughout, plus the dark secret involves traumatic themes (based on Hoover's typical subject matter: loss, grief, potentially pregnancy/infant death). The emotional manipulation and power imbalance in the central relationship could normalize unhealthy dynamics. Recommended for ages 18-21+ by parent communities. Definitely not safe for younger readers who might stumble into it.

Enriching

38

There's emotional weight here—grief, trauma, the messiness of trying to love someone who's shut down. Readers drawn to psychological complexity might find value in exploring how past pain shapes present behavior. But the 'love heals all wounds' resolution is simplistic, and the book doesn't really interrogate the toxicity of the arrangement. It's emotionally manipulative in a way that prioritizes drama over genuine insight. Entertainment value is high for the target audience, but growth potential is limited.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Hoover writes emotional intensity well—if you want to feel things (angst, longing, heartbreak), she delivers
Dual timeline structure (present prose, past in verse) adds narrative interest
Explores how trauma and grief can freeze someone emotionally, making connection nearly impossible
For adult readers who enjoy angsty romance with high drama and explicit scenes, this hits the marks

⚠

What to Watch For

Explicit sexual content throughout—this is adult romance, not YA
The central relationship is a textbook case of emotional unavailability: he sets all the rules, she accepts crumbs and hopes he'll change
Dark themes including trauma, grief, and likely infant or pregnancy loss
The 'broken man needs patient woman to heal him' trope reinforces problematic relationship dynamics
Despite the 4.6 Amazon rating, parent communities are clear: this is for adults 18-21+, not teens

Conversation Starters

"If someone tells you 'no questions, no future,' what does that say about how they see you?"
"Why do you think Tate agreed to Miles's rules? Would you ever accept a relationship on someone else's terms like that?"
"Can love actually heal trauma, or does that put unfair pressure on a partner to be someone's therapist?"
"What would a healthy version of this relationship look like—where both people have equal say?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic