Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
This is solid middle-grade storytelling that doesn't try to be more than it is. The premise—twins growing apart in sixth grade—is straightforward, but Johnson and Wright handle it with emotional intelligence and visual charm.
It's not groundbreaking, but it's exactly the kind of book that helps kids process the weird, painful reality that people change, friendships evolve, and that's actually okay even when it hurts. The graphic novel format is a huge plus for visual learners or kids who claim they "hate reading."
If your kid is dealing with friendship drama, sibling rivalry, or just trying to figure out who they are separate from their best friend, this will land. It's empathetic without being sappy, real without being devastating.
Age Fit
Perfect for 8-12 year olds navigating the social minefield of late elementary and middle school. The graphic novel format makes it accessible for younger or reluctant readers, while the emotional complexity keeps older middle-schoolers engaged.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
88
Tackles the natural growing pains of sibling relationships with emotional honesty. Shows both twins navigating identity and independence without villainizing either perspective. Models healthy conflict resolution around changing friendships and family bonds.
Imaginative
72
Graphic novel format brings visual creativity to a fairly straightforward middle school story. The premise of twins growing apart is relatable but not particularly inventive—it's more observational than imaginative. Wright's cartooning adds personality, though the narrative itself stays grounded in realistic scenarios.
Safe
95
Age-appropriate middle-grade content with no concerning themes. Focuses on friendship dynamics, identity, and typical sixth-grade social situations. No violence, mature content, or unexpected triggers. Amazon rating of 4.7 suggests strong parent approval.
Enriching
82
Strong emotional learning around identity formation, sibling relationships, and the reality that people grow and change—even twins. Validates both the need for independence and the fear of losing closeness. Varian Johnson (Coretta Scott King Honor author) brings thoughtful character development to middle-grade struggles.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
Graphic novel format makes it perfect for kids who need visual engagement or are transitioning to chapter books
Validates the weird, painful reality that best friends (even twin sisters) can grow apart—and that's okay
Written by Coretta Scott King Honor author Varian Johnson, who knows how to handle middle-grade emotions without being preachy
Shows both perspectives: the twin who wants change AND the twin who's terrified of it
Tackles identity formation in that crucial 6th grade moment when everyone's figuring out who they are
⚠
What to Watch For
Kids who are currently dealing with friendship changes might find it validating—or might find it hits too close to home
The story doesn't wrap everything up in a perfect bow, which is realistic but might frustrate kids who want clear resolutions
If your kid IS a twin, this could spark some real feelings about their own relationship
Conversation Starters
"Have you ever felt like a friend was changing and leaving you behind? What did that feel like?"
"Do you think Maureen and Francine will stay close even though they're becoming different people?"
"If you could join any club or activity without worrying what your friends think, what would it be?"
"Is it okay to want different things than your sibling or best friend? Why is that scary sometimes?"
