Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

Where to Read

Amazon

Barnes & Noble

Libby

Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased, but as an Amazon Associate, Screenwise earns an affiliate fee if you buy a book or game by clicking one of our links. We don't get any credit if you just Google it instead :)

Screenwise Verdict

Look, Treasure Island is a legitimate classic that earned its place in the canon. It's genuinely exciting, invented half the pirate tropes we know, and Long John Silver is an all-timer villain. Jim Hawkins' journey from inn-keeper's son to treasure-hunting survivor is compelling.

But let's be real: this is a 142-year-old book, and it reads like one. The prose is dense, the pacing is 19th-century, and modern kids raised on Percy Jackson and Harry Potter may find it tough going. If your kid is a strong reader who likes classics, they'll probably dig it. If they struggle with older language, there are abridged 'young reader' editions that smooth things out.

The content is rougher than you might expect from a 'classic'—pirates drink constantly, people die, there's betrayal and murder. It's not gratuitous, but it's not Narnia either. Common Sense Media users peg it at 9+, which feels right for maturity, though reading level might push that to 10-11 for independent reading.

Bottom line: if your kid wants to read a real pirate adventure and can handle the language, this is the one. Just don't be surprised if they need some help getting through it.

Age Fit

Best for confident readers ages 10-14 who can handle Victorian prose and pirate violence. Younger kids (8-9) might enjoy it read aloud if they can follow the language. Teens and adults still read it, but it's primarily a middle-grade classic.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

72

Classic adventure tale with themes of loyalty, courage, and coming-of-age. Jim Hawkins grows from boy to young man through adversity. Pirates drink rum constantly and there's violence (murder, battles), but it's handled in a period-appropriate, non-gratuitous way. The moral complexity of Long John Silver—villain yet charismatic—is actually rich territory. Not squeaky clean, but emotionally grounded.

Imaginative

88

One of the defining adventure novels that basically invented the pirate genre as we know it. Treasure maps, buried gold, mutiny on the high seas, a one-legged cook with a parrot—Stevenson created archetypes that have fired imaginations for 140+ years. The world-building is vivid and transportive, inviting kids to dream of sailing ships and hidden treasure.

Safe

68

Violence is present but not graphic—people die in battles, there's murder and treachery, but described in 19th-century prose rather than gory detail. Pirates are 'rum-obsessed' and there's drinking throughout. No sexual content, no modern trigger warnings, but definitely has peril and death. Common Sense Media user reviews suggest ages 9+ with parents noting 'some drinking and violence.' For a classic, it's relatively safe, but not a gentle read.

Enriching

82

Rich vocabulary and sentence structure from 1883 prose—genuinely challenging reading that builds literary muscle. Themes of greed, betrayal, moral ambiguity, and courage offer discussion fodder. Jim's navigation of trust and danger provides real character study. Historical context of seafaring life is educational. That said, it's a ripping yarn first, literature second—entertainment and enrichment balanced well.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Literally invented the pirate genre: treasure maps with X marks the spot, parrots on shoulders, 'yo-ho-ho and a bottle of rum'—all Stevenson
Jim Hawkins is a genuinely compelling young protagonist navigating danger, betrayal, and moral complexity
Long John Silver remains one of literature's most memorable villains—charismatic, terrifying, and morally ambiguous
Builds serious reading stamina and vocabulary with rich 19th-century prose
A legitimate classic that's actually still exciting if your kid can handle the language

⚠

What to Watch For

Violence and death throughout—pirates kill each other, battles happen, murder is discussed. Not graphic but definitely present
Constant references to rum and drunkenness—these are not family-friendly pirates
The prose is genuinely challenging for modern readers. Written in 1883, it reads like 1883. Some kids will bounce right off
Pacing is slower than modern adventure novels—more descriptive passages, less constant action

Conversation Starters

"Why do you think Jim keeps going back and forth about whether to trust Long John Silver?"
"If you found a treasure map, would you tell anyone or keep it secret? Who would you trust?"
"The pirates are the bad guys, but Stevenson makes some of them pretty interesting. Why do you think he did that?"
"What would be the hardest part of being on a sailing ship for months—no phones, no showers, just hardtack and salt pork?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic