2020
WISE Score
Amazon
A 24-hour Seattle scavenger hunt where academic rivals realize they don't actually hate each other—they're just both incredibly stressed and nerdy.
4.3
4.3View →Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased, but as an Amazon Associate, Screenwise earns an affiliate fee if you buy a book or game by clicking one of our links. We don't get any credit if you just Google it instead :)
Today Tonight Tomorrow is a rare YA romance that feels both aspirational and grounded. It’s smart, it’s fast-paced, and it avoids the 'brain rot' tropes of lesser teen fiction.
It’s basically 'Booksmart' meets 'Before Sunrise.' If you have a teen who's currently obsessing over college apps or crying over their last high school yearbook, this will hit the spot. It’s a high-quality read that respects its audience’s intelligence.
This is squarely for the 14+ crowd. It deals with senior-year milestones—graduation, sex, and the 'what am I doing with my life' panic—in a way that resonates most with high schoolers.
The emotional arc is rock solid. It moves from bitter academic rivalry to a relationship built on mutual respect and vulnerability. The Jewish representation is integrated naturally, and the characters actually talk through their insecurities like real people.
While it's a grounded contemporary romance, the 'Howl' scavenger hunt across Seattle adds a layer of adventure and urban exploration that makes the setting feel alive and interactive.
It's a YA book, so it's generally low-risk. However, there is a frank, sex-positive scene toward the end and some mature language. It's totally appropriate for the intended teen audience but might be a 'talk about it first' moment for younger middle schoolers.
It tackles the crushing pressure of high school achievement and the fear of the future with a lot of grace. It also does a great job dismantling the 'smart girls can't like 'frivolous' things' trope.
If you’ve spent any time on BookTok or browsing teen fiction lately, you know the "academic rivals" trope has a total stranglehold on the genre. Today Tonight Tomorrow is the gold standard for that specific vibe. Rachel Lynn Solomon takes the "I hate you because you’re the only person as smart as me" energy and puts it in a pressure cooker by setting the entire story over a single 24-hour period.
The conflict between Rowan Roth and Neil McNair feels authentic because it’s rooted in something real: the absolute panic of senior year. These aren't just two kids who bicker for the sake of the plot. They are two people who have defined their entire identities by being better than each other. When they’re forced to team up for "Howl"—a city-wide scavenger hunt that serves as a high-stakes farewell to Seattle—the book moves past the "enemies" phase and gets into the "who am I if I’m not winning?" phase.
It captures that frantic, bittersweet feeling of being eighteen and realizing your childhood is ending at exactly 11:59 PM. If your teen is currently losing sleep over AP exams or college admissions, they will see themselves in Rowan’s obsession with being valedictorian.
A lot of YA romance can feel like "brain rot"—low-effort plots where the characters have no personality outside of being in love. This book avoids that by giving Rowan a specific, slightly embarrassing passion: she wants to write romance novels but is terrified people will think she’s shallow for it. It’s a meta-commentary on the book itself and adds a layer of vulnerability that makes her feel like a person, not a character archetype.
The Seattle setting also isn't just window dressing. The scavenger hunt hits actual landmarks and local favorites, making the city feel like a third main character. It’s a love letter to a place, which gives the story more weight than a generic high school hallway setting.
Let’s be real: when a YA book gets this much buzz, parents usually want to know about the maturity level. This isn't a chaste story for middle schoolers. It’s a book about seniors who are about to head to college, and the content reflects that transition. There is a specific, descriptive sexual encounter near the end that focuses heavily on consent and emotional intimacy. If you want a breakdown of the specific "spice" levels, the language, or the casual mentions of weed, check out our Today Tonight Tomorrow: Rivals, Romance, and the 'Spicy' Truth.
This is the perfect "next step" for fans of movies like Booksmart. It has that same high-energy, one-night-to-fix-everything pacing. It also pairs well with anyone who enjoyed the academic friction in The Hating Game, but it’s written with a much more grounded teen perspective.
The Jewish representation is also a standout feature. It’s woven into the characters' daily lives and family dynamics naturally. It’s not a "struggle story" about religion; it’s just a part of who they are while they’re busy running around Seattle trying to win a game and not fall in love. It’s refreshing to see that identity treated as a default rather than a plot point.
Get a personalized guide on any topic
