This is a perfectly fine sequel that does absolutely nothing wrong and also nothing particularly memorable. It's comfort viewing—sweet, safe, and earnest in a way that feels increasingly rare. The ratings tell the real story: critics appreciated its wholesomeness, but audiences (especially fans of the first film) found it flat.

The love triangle is telegraphed from frame one, and there's zero tension about who Lara Jean will choose. That said, for younger teens dipping their toes into romance narratives, this is about as safe and emotionally healthy as it gets. The family dynamics are lovely, the communication lessons are solid, and there's nothing here that'll give you pause.

The problem? It's just kind of boring. The first film had novelty; this one feels like it's going through the motions. If your kid loved the original and wants more, sure—but don't expect lightning to strike twice. It's the cinematic equivalent of a warm blanket: comforting, but not exactly thrilling.