This is the real deal—a middle-grade mystery with genuine literary chops and a narrator you'll want to hang out with. Mo LoBeau's voice is sharp, funny, and completely authentic, carrying you through 312 pages that never feel like a slog.

The murder mystery is actually engaging (not the usual middle-grade "who stole the mascot" fare), and the found-family dynamics give it emotional weight without veering into after-school-special territory. Turnage trusts her readers to handle complexity—both in the mystery plotting and in the themes around abandonment, belonging, and what makes a home.

Yes, there are some mature elements (murder, references to an abusive parent), but they're handled with care and age-appropriately. This isn't trauma porn; it's a thoughtful book that respects its readers' ability to process difficult topics. The Newbery Honor wasn't a fluke—this is quality writing with substance.

The main barrier is length and commitment. At 312 pages, it's for kids who already like reading, not reluctant readers you're trying to hook. But for the right kid? This is the kind of book that sticks with you.