Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

Where to Watch

Loading streaming options...

Screenwise Verdict

This is exceptional documentary filmmaking that brings WWI to life in a way that's both technically brilliant and deeply moving. Peter Jackson's restoration work is genuinely groundbreaking—watching century-old footage transformed into vivid, modern-looking color makes history feel immediate in a way that's almost shocking.

But let's be clear: this is R-rated for very good reason. The graphic violence—mangled bodies, bloody wounds, dead soldiers—is extreme and disturbing. One kid reviewer on Common Sense Media put it perfectly: "Don't show it to your kids unless you want them to have a really good idea of what a human corpse looks like."

For older teens (16+) and adults, especially those studying WWI or interested in history, this is must-watch material. The first-person soldier testimonies are profound and the film honors their experiences without glorifying war. But younger viewers? Absolutely not. This is one to save for when they're ready to process the brutal reality of war.

Age Fit

This is strictly for older teens (16+) and adults. The graphic war imagery is too disturbing for younger viewers, even mature middle schoolers. But for high schoolers studying WWI or anyone interested in history, this is essential viewing that makes the past feel present.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

45

This is a documentary that treats its subject with profound respect and dignity, honoring the soldiers' experiences without glorification. However, the graphic wartime violence—mangled corpses, bloody wounds, dead bodies—is emotionally heavy and disturbing. It's historically important but not emotionally healthy viewing for younger audiences.

Imaginative

88

Peter Jackson's restoration and colorization of WWI footage is genuinely groundbreaking filmmaking. The technical innovation—transforming century-old black-and-white film into vivid, modern-looking footage—makes history feel immediate and real in a way that invites viewers to reimagine the past. The creative approach transforms archival material into something that feels alive.

Safe

25

Rated R for disturbing war images. Common Sense Media age 16+. The violence is extreme and graphic: mangled corpses, bloody gory wounds, dead bodies, horrifying battlefield images. This is exactly the kind of content that would be inappropriate and traumatizing for a young child to encounter unexpectedly. The imagery is unforgettable and deeply disturbing, even if historically accurate.

Enriching

92

Extraordinarily enriching for older teens and adults. The first-person soldier testimonies provide profound insight into WWI experiences, building empathy and historical understanding. It's educational without being preachy, showing the reality of war in a way that textbooks never could. The 99% Rotten Tomatoes score and 91 Metacritic reflect its impact. This is essential historical viewing that teaches without lecturing.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Groundbreaking restoration work that makes century-old footage feel immediate and real—the colorization and technical innovation is genuinely remarkable
First-person soldier testimonies provide profound, unfiltered insight into WWI trench warfare that no textbook could match
Treats its subject with deep respect and dignity, honoring soldiers' experiences without glorifying war
99% on Rotten Tomatoes and 91 on Metacritic—this is historically significant filmmaking that's also compelling to watch
Educational in the best way: shows rather than tells, letting viewers understand the human cost of war through authentic voices

⚠

What to Watch For

Extreme graphic violence: mangled corpses, bloody wounds, dead bodies—this is R-rated for very good reason and will be disturbing even for many adults
The imagery is unforgettable and potentially traumatizing for younger viewers—Common Sense Media recommends 16+ and that feels right
Despite the horror, most of the soldiers' narration is matter-of-fact, which can be its own kind of haunting
This is not background viewing—it demands attention and emotional processing

Conversation Starters

"What surprised you most about what daily life was like for these soldiers?"
"Why do you think Peter Jackson chose to colorize and restore this footage instead of leaving it in black and white?"
"How did hearing the soldiers' own words change your understanding of WWI compared to what you learned in school?"
"What do you think about the way the film shows war without glorifying it?"
"How do you think these soldiers would feel knowing their stories are being watched 100+ years later?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic

They Shall Not Grow Old