Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

Where to Read

Amazon

Barnes & Noble

Libby

Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased, but as an Amazon Associate, Screenwise earns an affiliate fee if you buy a book or game by clicking one of our links. We don't get any credit if you just Google it instead :)

Screenwise Verdict

This is a legitimately good book—Chloe Gong can write, the 1920s Shanghai setting is immersive and fresh, and the Romeo and Juliet reimagining actually works. The 4.7 Amazon rating and NYT bestseller status aren't flukes.

But let's be clear: this is violent. Not action-movie violent, but horror-fantasy violent. People tear their own throats out in graphic detail. Common Sense Media isn't exaggerating. If your teen loved Six of Crows or The Poppy War, they can probably handle this. If they're coming from Percy Jackson or even Hunger Games, pump the brakes.

The historical and cultural richness is real—readers will learn about colonialism, Chinese gang dynamics, and 1920s Shanghai in ways that stick. The character work is strong, especially Juliette as a complicated female lead navigating impossible choices.

Bottom line: excellent book for the right reader, but that reader needs to be 16-17+ and okay with body horror. Don't let a 13-year-old pick this up just because it's YA and has a pretty cover.

Age Fit

Best for mature 16-17+ readers who can handle graphic violence and body horror. The historical-fantasy setting and literary quality appeal to older teens and adults, but the intense gore makes it inappropriate for middle schoolers despite the YA label.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

58

A Romeo and Juliet retelling that centers on love, loyalty, and cooperation between rivals, but the emotional tone is dark with blood feuds, betrayal, and significant violence. The relationship dynamics between Juliette and Roma model working through conflict, but the setting of gang warfare and the graphic violence (people tearing their own throats out) creates a heavy, intense atmosphere that isn't emotionally nurturing for younger readers.

Imaginative

82

Reimagining Romeo and Juliet in 1920s Shanghai with gang warfare and fantasy/horror elements is genuinely creative. Gong blends historical fiction with supernatural mystery, creating a lush, atmospheric world that invites readers into a specific time and place they likely haven't encountered before. The premise of star-crossed heirs forced to collaborate against a shadowy threat offers fresh narrative territory beyond the source material.

Safe

42

Common Sense Media explicitly flags 'lots of fantasy violence, including gory descriptions of people tearing their own throats out.' This is graphic body horror that would be shocking and disturbing for younger or unsuspecting readers. Multiple sources suggest age 17+ recommendations. The violence isn't just present—it's visceral and described in detail. For a book, this crosses into unsafe territory for younger teens who might pick it up based on the Romeo and Juliet hook without understanding the horror elements.

Enriching

76

Strong historical and cultural elements expose readers to 1920s Shanghai, Chinese gang dynamics, and colonialism. The Romeo and Juliet framework invites literary analysis and comparison. Themes of loyalty, identity, choosing between family duty and personal conviction, and navigating impossible choices offer meaningful ethical complexity. The book has earned NYT bestseller status and critical acclaim, suggesting it delivers substance alongside entertainment. However, the enrichment is somewhat limited by the genre conventions and YA romance focus.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Genuinely fresh take on Romeo and Juliet that doesn't feel like homework—1920s Shanghai with flappers, gangs, and colonialism is a killer setting
Juliette Cai is a strong female lead who's a gang heir, not just a lovesick teenager—she's got agency and complexity
The historical detail and cultural specificity offer real learning about a time/place most teens haven't encountered
NYT bestseller with strong critical reception and a 4.7 Amazon rating—readers genuinely love this duology
Forces readers to grapple with loyalty, family duty vs. personal conviction, and impossible moral choices

⚠

What to Watch For

The violence is GRAPHIC—people literally tear their own throats out, and it's described in gory detail, not glossed over
This is horror-fantasy, not just historical romance—if your teen is squeamish about body horror, this isn't it
The Romeo and Juliet framework means you know tragedy is coming—emotionally heavy ending
Best for mature 16-17+ readers; younger teens who loved Hunger Games might think they're ready but this is gorier

Conversation Starters

"How does setting Romeo and Juliet in 1920s Shanghai change the story? What does the gang warfare add that the original family feud didn't have?"
"Juliette has to choose between her family's expectations and what she thinks is right—have you ever felt that kind of conflict?"
"The book shows colonialism and foreign powers in Shanghai—what did you learn about that period of history?"
"Roma and Juliette have to work together despite their history—when have you had to collaborate with someone you didn't trust?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic

These Violent Delights