The Witch Boy Molly Knox Ostertag – WISE Score & Parent Review | Screenwise

The Witch Boy Molly Knox Ostertag

Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

book2017

85%

WISE Score

4.7

Amazon

A boy who wants to be a witch in a family where magic is strictly gendered—charming, thoughtful, and perfect for kids questioning the rules.

The Witch Boy Molly Knox Ostertag

book

2017

85%

WISE Score

4.7

Amazon

A boy who wants to be a witch in a family where magic is strictly gendered—charming, thoughtful, and perfect for kids questioning the rules.

4.7

Jump to

Also rated on

4.7

View →

Where to Read

Amazon

Barnes & Noble

Libby

Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased, but as an Amazon Associate, Screenwise earns an affiliate fee if you buy a book or game by clicking one of our links. We don't get any credit if you just Google it instead :)

Screenwise Verdict

The Witch Boy is that rare middle-grade book that tackles Big Themes—gender roles, family pressure, being true to yourself—without feeling like homework. The graphic novel format keeps it visually engaging, and the magic system is creative enough to hook fantasy fans.

Is it a masterpiece of plot complexity? No. Reviews consistently note it's 'light on plot' and 'cute' rather than gripping. But that's not necessarily a problem for the target age. The emotional journey is solid, the art is charming, and it opens up great conversations about questioning unfair rules and supporting people who don't fit the mold.

For families looking for inclusive, thoughtful fantasy that doesn't talk down to kids, this delivers. It's especially great for kids who feel like they don't fit in, or who are starting to question why things 'have to be' a certain way. And if they love it, there are two more books in the series.

Age Fit

Best for ages 8-13, though younger kids who love graphic novels could handle it with some guidance on the identity themes. Older middle schoolers might find the plot a touch simple, but the themes still resonate.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

Models courage, self-acceptance, and challenging unjust traditions. Aster's journey to be himself despite family pressure is emotionally healthy and age-appropriate. The friendship with Charlie (a non-magical, non-conforming character) demonstrates acceptance and support. Themes of gender roles and identity are handled thoughtfully for middle-grade readers without being preachy. Tone is warm and encouraging.

Imaginative

Creative world-building with a magic system that divides witches (girls) and shapeshifters (boys) along gender lines. The graphic novel format invites visual engagement. However, reviews note the plot is 'a little light' and some describe it as cute but not deeply complex. Still, the concept of crossing forbidden magical boundaries and the supernatural fantasy elements spark curiosity. The world feels well-thought-out even if execution is straightforward.

Safe

No concerning content flags. Parent reviews on Common Sense Media specifically note 'fantasy story without sexuality' and praise its accessibility for younger audiences. The mysterious danger threatening the boys is age-appropriate tension without graphic violence or trauma. As a book, there are no privacy, monetization, or social feature concerns. The themes of non-conformity and gender identity are presented sensitively for the middle-grade audience.

Enriching

Strong themes of identity, courage, and challenging rigid social expectations. Explores gender roles, family pressure, and finding your authentic self in ways that build empathy and self-reflection. The story encourages kids to question unfair rules and support friends who are different. Parent reviews note it's 'compelling' with issues of 'gender, identity, and fitting in with your family' explored accessibly. Solid 4.7 Amazon rating suggests readers find value. It's meaningful without being heavy-handed.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Tackles gender expectations and self-acceptance in an accessible, fantasy-wrapped package that doesn't feel like a lecture
Graphic novel format makes it approachable for reluctant readers or kids transitioning to longer books
Models real courage—not slaying dragons, but being yourself when your whole family says you shouldn't
Charlie, the non-magical friend, shows that you don't need powers to be supportive and brave
First in a trilogy, so if your kid loves it, there's more to read

⚠

What to Watch For

The plot is straightforward—this isn't a twisty, complex fantasy, so advanced readers might find it a bit simple
Themes of gender non-conformity are central; most families will appreciate this, but know it's there
Some mild peril when boys are threatened by mysterious danger, but nothing graphic or traumatic

Conversation Starters

"Why do you think Aster's family has such strict rules about who can be a witch? Have you ever felt like rules didn't make sense?"
"What would you do if you were really good at something but people told you it wasn't for you?"
"Charlie doesn't have magic but still helps Aster. What makes someone a good friend?"
"If you could be a witch or a shapeshifter, which would you pick and why?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic