Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

Where to Read

Amazon

Barnes & Noble

Libby

Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased, but as an Amazon Associate, Screenwise earns an affiliate fee if you buy a book or game by clicking one of our links. We don't get any credit if you just Google it instead :)

Screenwise Verdict

Look, this isn't your kid's Goosebumps collection. The White Guy Dies First is smart, bold, unapologetically graphic horror that uses scares to interrogate racism and power. It's got cannibalism, body horror, and violence that earned consistent 'strong stomachs only' warnings from every major reviewer.

But here's the thing—for teens who love horror and are ready for mature themes, this is genuinely enriching. It's not gore for gore's sake. Each story uses horror conventions to explore real experiences of marginalized communities, cultural appropriation, and systemic racism. The anthology format means exposure to diverse voices and storytelling traditions you won't find in mainstream horror.

The 13+ recommendation is spot-on, but honestly, think 14-15+ unless your teen is a serious horror fan. This requires both the stomach for graphic content and the emotional maturity to unpack heavy social themes. If your kid devoured Mexican Gothic or watches A24 horror films, they'll probably appreciate this. If they're still working through Stranger Things, wait a year or two.

Bottom line: It's well-executed, meaningful horror with a 4.1 Amazon rating, but you need to know your kid's tolerance for intense, disturbing content before handing this over.

Age Fit

This is firmly teen territory—13+ who actively seek out horror and can handle graphic, mature content. Not for middle schoolers still reading Percy Jackson, but perfect for high schoolers ready for Jordan Peele-style horror with social bite.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

45

This horror anthology deliberately confronts racism, violence, and power dynamics through graphic horror imagery including cannibalism, body modification, and violent murders. While the social justice themes are valuable, the execution involves strong language, sexual violence references, and intense psychological horror that creates a dark, heavy reading experience. Multiple reviewers note it's 'not for the faint of heart' and requires 'strong stomachs.' The emotional tone is intentionally disturbing rather than nurturing, though the underlying message about representation and power has merit.

Imaginative

82

Flipping the classic horror trope where 'the white guy dies first' is genuinely creative and fresh. Thirteen different authors of color bring diverse cultural perspectives—Indigenous, Korean-American, transgender experiences—creating a rich tapestry of horror styles from body horror to vengeful ghosts to unreliable narrators. The anthology format encourages varied storytelling approaches, and using horror as a lens for social commentary is intellectually bold. Stories like 'Best Served Cold' (cultural appropriation as cannibalism metaphor) and 'Break Through Our Skin' (trans body-horror allegory) show real originality in genre-bending.

Safe

35

Contains graphic horror content including cannibalism, violent murders, body modification, strong language, sexual violence, and mature themes around systemic racism and trauma. All reviewers consistently recommend ages 13+ and warn about intense, disturbing content. For teens who choose horror and understand what they're getting into, it's appropriately labeled. However, the graphic nature and heavy themes mean this could be genuinely distressing for younger or sensitive readers who encounter it unexpectedly. The content warnings are clear, which helps, but the material itself is objectively intense.

Enriching

78

This is horror with purpose. Each story uses scares to explore real-world power dynamics, representation, cultural appropriation, racism, and identity. For teens ready to engage with these themes, it offers meaningful conversations about who gets to be the hero, whose stories get told, and how marginalized communities experience fear differently. The anthology format exposes readers to diverse voices and storytelling traditions. It builds critical thinking about genre conventions and social justice. However, the heavy content means the enrichment comes with emotional labor—this isn't light learning.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Genuinely fresh take on tired horror tropes, centering marginalized voices and perspectives
Uses horror as a vehicle for real conversations about racism, cultural appropriation, and power dynamics
Diverse storytelling styles from body horror to psychological thrillers to vengeful ghost tales
Strong 4.1 Amazon rating suggests readers are connecting with the bold concept
Perfect for teens who want their scares with substance and social commentary

⚠

What to Watch For

Graphic content throughout—cannibalism, violent deaths, body modification, sexual violence references
Heavy themes around racism and trauma that require emotional maturity to process
Strong language and intense psychological horror; multiple reviewers say 'not for the faint of heart'
This is deliberately disturbing horror, not thriller-lite—make sure your teen actually enjoys being scared

Conversation Starters

"Why do you think horror movies and books have traditionally killed off people of color first? What does flipping that trope reveal?"
"Which story hit you hardest, and what real-world issue was it exploring through the horror?"
"How does it change a story when the protagonist and author share similar backgrounds or experiences?"
"Do you think horror is a good genre for talking about serious social issues, or does the scary stuff distract from the message?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic