The Summer of Broken Rules

The Summer of Broken Rules

book

2021, Young Adult Fiction

WISE
84%

WISE Score

A Martha's Vineyard wedding, a high-stakes game of Assassin, and enough Taylor Swift vibes to keep any teen turning pages.

Where to Read

Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased, but as an Amazon Associate, Screenwise earns an affiliate fee if you buy a book or game by clicking one of our links. We don't get any credit if you just Google it instead :)

Screenwise Verdict

The Summer of Broken Rules is the ultimate summer vibe. It’s a BookTok darling for a reason: it manages to be both a light, fun romance and a heartfelt look at family and loss. If your teen is currently in their 'Swiftie Era' or obsessed with The Summer I Turned Pretty, this is a guaranteed hit.

It’s refreshing to see a YA novel where the family isn’t the enemy. The Fox family is loud, competitive, and genuinely loves each other, which makes the wedding backdrop feel lived-in and real. It’s safe, sweet, and actually has a plot beyond just 'will they/won't they' thanks to the water-gun-assassin-game stakes.

Age Fit

Perfect for 12 to 17-year-olds. It’s the 'gateway drug' for younger teens moving from middle-grade into YA romance, especially if they already love Jenny Han or Sarah Dessen.

WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
85

The core of the book is a massive, multi-generational family reunion. It models healthy (if competitive) family dynamics and shows a protagonist navigating grief with the support of her community.

Imaginative
72

While it's a standard contemporary romance, the inclusion of a week-long, high-stakes game of 'Assassin' adds a layer of strategy and playful creativity to the setting.

Safe
88

Standard Young Adult romance territory. There is some mild language and teenage romance (kissing, heavy making out), but it avoids explicit content. The heaviest element is the recent death of a sibling.

Enriching
78

It offers a meaningful look at how to move forward after loss without 'moving on' from the person you loved. It also highlights the value of tradition and family history.

Parent Info

Why It Might Be Great

  • Taylor Swift fans will love the Easter eggs—the author literally structured the book around Swift's discography and 'eras' vibes.
  • The Assassin game adds a fun, tactical edge that keeps the plot moving faster than a typical 'beach read' romance.
  • It handles grief with nuance, showing that it's okay to have fun and fall in love even while mourning a massive loss.
  • The setting is immersive; you can practically smell the salt air of Martha's Vineyard and feel the chaos of a 14-person family house.

What to Watch For

  • The grief is heavy at times. The protagonist is mourning her sister who died by suicide (though details are kept relatively light), which could be a trigger for some readers.
  • Expect some teenage drinking and mild swearing, consistent with typical YA summer-break scenarios.
  • The romance includes physical intimacy, though it stays 'closed-door' or focused on emotional connection rather than explicit detail.

Conversation Starters

  • "If our family played a week-long game of Assassin, who would be the first one out and who would win?"
  • "Meredith feels guilty for being happy while missing her sister. Is it possible to hold both of those feelings at the same time?"
  • "Which Taylor Swift song do you think best fits Meredith and Wit's relationship?"
  • "Why do you think traditions like the Fox family's game are so important to them, even during a wedding?"

Deep Dive

The 'Assassin' Hook

What separates this from the mountain of other YA romances on the shelf is the Game. In the Fox family, 'Assassin' is a blood sport played with water guns and strict rules during their annual Martha's Vineyard retreat. Meredith, the protagonist, sees winning the game as the only way to honor her late sister, Claire, who was a legendary player. This adds a layer of strategy and tension that makes the book feel active. It’s not just two people staring at each other on a beach; it’s two people trying to hunt each other down while also falling in love.

The Swiftie Connection

K.L. Walther doesn't hide her inspiration. The book is essentially a love letter to Taylor Swift's songwriting. For a parent, this might seem like a gimmick, but for the target audience, it’s a feature, not a bug. The chapters evoke specific moods—from the 'Folklore' salt-air vibes to the 'Lover' era romance. It creates an instant shorthand for the reader to understand the emotional stakes.

Handling the Heavy Stuff

While the marketing screams 'fun summer read,' the book deals with the aftermath of a sister's death. It doesn't wallow, but it doesn't ignore it either. It’s a great example of 'bibliotherapy' for teens who might be dealing with their own losses, showing that joy isn't a betrayal of the person who is gone. If you're looking for a book that has a bit more meat on its bones than a standard beach read, this is a solid pick.

What Parents Ask

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic