The School for Good and Evil – WISE Score & Parent Review | Screenwise

The School for Good and Evil

Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

book2007

74%

WISE Score

4.5

Amazon

What if Cinderella's school had an Evil campus next door? This fairy tale mashup asks whether you're born good or bad—or if it's more complicated.

The School for Good and Evil

book

2007

74%

WISE Score

4.5

Amazon

What if Cinderella's school had an Evil campus next door? This fairy tale mashup asks whether you're born good or bad—or if it's more complicated.

4.5

Jump to

Also rated on

4.5

View →

Where to Read

Amazon

Barnes & Noble

Libby

Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased, but as an Amazon Associate, Screenwise earns an affiliate fee if you buy a book or game by clicking one of our links. We don't get any credit if you just Google it instead :)

Screenwise Verdict

This is a smart, entertaining twist on fairy tales that became a bestseller for good reason. The premise is genuinely clever—two best friends get sorted into opposite schools, forcing them (and readers) to question what 'good' and 'evil' really mean.

The friendship between Sophie and Agatha is the heart of the story, and the book ultimately rewards inner character over outer appearance. That said, it's not for every family. The School for Evil is played for dark humor, but it's still literally teaching kids to be villains, which some parents will find off-putting. Conservative reviewers have real concerns about moral relativism.

For families comfortable with moral complexity and fantasy violence, this is a solid middle-grade read that hooks kids and gets them thinking. For families who prefer clearer moral lines, it might feel like it's celebrating villainy a bit too enthusiastically. Know your kid and your values.

Age Fit

Best for ages 9-13 who are ready for moral complexity and can handle the idea of a school that trains villains as a thought experiment. Too nuanced for younger kids who need clearer good/bad frameworks, and older teens will likely find it too middle-grade.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

The book explores friendship, identity, and the complexity of good vs. evil through Sophie and Agatha's reversed school placements. It models genuine friendship and challenges superficial judgments about appearance and behavior. However, the premise centers on training villains and includes content like 'Death Curses' and 'Uglification' classes that, while fantasy-based, may not be entirely emotionally nurturing. The book does ultimately reward inner character over outer beauty, showing growth and self-acceptance.

Imaginative

Highly creative premise that flips fairy tale conventions on their head. The dual-school concept (Good vs. Evil) is inventive and the role reversal of Sophie and Agatha creates compelling narrative tension. The world-building draws from classic fairy tales while creating something fresh. It invites readers to question assumptions about heroes and villains, appearance and reality. The fantasy setting encourages imaginative engagement with familiar stories in new ways.

Safe

As a middle-grade fantasy book, it's generally safe but has some content that warrants parent awareness. The School for Evil teaches 'Death Curses' and villain training, and there's fantasy violence typical of fairy tale retellings. Christian parent review sites flag concerns about the moral relativism of 'good vs. evil' being presented as equally valid paths. Common Sense Media parent reviews suggest ages 10-12+. No graphic content, but the thematic elements of training villains and the moral ambiguity may be uncomfortable for some families or younger readers. It's not a book that would traumatize, but it's not squeaky-clean either.

Enriching

Strong themes about not judging by appearances, the complexity of morality, and finding your true self. The book challenges binary thinking about good and evil, encouraging readers to consider that people are more nuanced than labels suggest. It explores genuine friendship, loyalty, and personal growth. The fairy tale framework provides cultural literacy while subverting expectations. However, some conservative reviewers note concerns about moral relativism. The book is entertaining and thought-provoking, though the 'enriching' elements are more about identity and friendship than traditional educational content.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Clever premise that subverts fairy tale expectations—pretty Sophie gets dumped in villain school while goth Agatha lands with the princesses
Strong friendship arc between two very different girls who learn not to judge by appearances
Encourages critical thinking about heroes and villains, good and evil, and whether those labels are as simple as we think
Engaging for kids who love fantasy but want something more complex than straightforward princess stories
Part of a bestselling series that hooks reluctant readers with humor and twists

⚠

What to Watch For

The School for Evil literally teaches villain skills—'Death Curses,' 'Henchmen Training,' etc. It's fantasy but some families may find the moral framework uncomfortable
Conservative Christian reviewers flag concerns about moral relativism and the idea that evil is just another valid path
Some fantasy violence and peril typical of middle-grade adventure, but nothing graphic
Best for kids who can handle nuance—the book challenges black-and-white thinking about morality

Conversation Starters

"Sophie thought she was 'good' because she's pretty and does nice things, but she gets sent to Evil school. Why do you think that happened?"
"Do you think people are born good or bad, or do they choose? Can someone be a little of both?"
"If you went to this school, which one do you think you'd end up in? Which one would you want to be in?"
"The book shows that heroes and villains aren't always what they seem. Can you think of a 'villain' who might have had good reasons for what they did?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic